[X]

Amtrak

Star Half star Empty star Empty star Empty star
44 Reviews & Complaints

Most Popular | Newest | More Options >
More filter options:
Amtrak - Never again
Posted by Cloudrider on 07/02/2010
In summary taking Amtrak was a terrible experience. Arrogant unfriendly personnel, dirty bathrooms, cold temperatures because A. C. is turned up too high, dirty windows, too uncomfortable to get any sleep, trains don’t run on time, for what they charge for a sleeper you may as well fly. I would never take Amtrak again, I would drive first.
Read the story -
Amtrak experience was terrible. We took the Southwest Chief from Chicago to L. A.
, CA, 2 Reserved Coach Seats, departed 09-JUN-10; 3:15 pm - arrival 11-JUN-10; 8:15 am . This is what we experienced on the trip to L. A.
We were assigned seats by an Amtrak employee before boarding the train. Our seats were #3 and #4 on the last car of the train. We had all of bags in place and were all settled in. Then about 20 min. after the train pulled out of the station, the attendant for our car who’s name is Francis told us that we could not sit in those seats, they were for her and that we had to move. I told her that we were assigned those seats at the station, she said that they didn’t know what they were doing and we had to move. We were some what embarrasssed in front of the other passengers, since Francis made us feel like we were trying to get away with something. So took our luggage and moved to the new seats. Shortly there after we decided to go to the observation car, we spent maybe an hour and a half in the observation car and returned to our seats. When we returned to our car there were 2 people sitting in the seats that Francis removed us from. When I asked Francis why there were people sitting in those seats she said they over booked the train so she had to seat them there. Well the train was not over booked. The rest of the evening and next day Francis sat in the seats across from this couple and spent a lot of time talking to them, I suspect they were her friends and she wanted them to sit in the back across from her and that’s why she moved us. Francis was arrogant and not very friendly, she seemed to be bothered if you asked her a question. She spent a lot of her time texting on her cell phone. Sometime during the second day she moved up to the car in front of us along with her friends. Some other people then sat in the seats she removed us from.
All of the windows on the train were dirty, the windows on the observation car were very dirty, we could hardly see out of some of the windows, very disappointing since that’s one of the reasons for riding the train.
The bathrooms were always dirty but by the second day the sinks were clogged up, water was to the top. Some were out of paper towels. I saw a passenger put paper towels in one of the bathrooms, I don’t know where she got them from. I guess Francis was too busy texting.
During the second evening my wife came back from the restroom and told me that when she passed the baggage area she didn’t see one of my suit cases. I went down to the baggage area and could not find one of my suit cases. I was now almost frantic thinking of the things I had in my bag that would be lost. I informed one of the conductors that my bag was missing, he went down to the baggage area with me, asked me to describe my bag, I did, he then took me to another car, showed me a bag that was stored above a seat that had a passenger in it and asked me if that was my bag, and it was. He told me that sometimes they move people's bags from the baggage area so that can have room for larger suit cases. How can they move people's bags with out telling them. If my wife hadn’t noticed that my bag was missing what would I have done when we got to our destination. Amtrak has no consideration for it’s passengers.
Forget about trying to sleep in coach. The seats are very uncomfortable, they give you a very small pillow about 12” by 8” and don’t even think of asking for two. The temperature was freezing at night, they wouldn’t turn off the air, grown men were bundle led up in blankets and wore hoodies. Also the aisle lights are so bright they keep you awake, I was lucky if I got an hour of sleep each night.
No A. C. outlets by the passenger seats. The only electrical A. C. outlets were 2 of them on the observation car, of course everyone and their brother wanted to plug in.
We were almost an hour late leaving Albuquerque, N. M., the morning of our arrival the conductor told me we would be a good 45 min. late arriving in L. A. So I called my son who was picking us up that we would be about an hour late. I don’t know how the engineer did it but we ended up getting to L. A. around 45 min earlier than what our original scheduled time was. So of course we had a long wait at the L. A. station for my son to pick us up.

The return trip, Southwest Chief, from Los Angeles to Chicago 19-JUN-10; 6:55 pm – arrival 21-JUN-10; 3:10 pm.
The return trip was slightly better than the train going out. But again we had a rude, arrogant attendant named Antonio. Again the air was turned way up and it was freezing at night. Earlier in the day an elderly man asked Antonio if he could turn the air down since it was cold on the car, Antonio was almost rude to him and told him that he couldn’t and wouldn’t turn it down. That evening I asked Antonio to turn down the air, it was too cold to try and sleep, again grown men were bundled in blankets wearing hoodies. Antonio told me that if tried to turn down the air he might break it and then we wouldn’t have air conditioning the next day, what kind of crap is that. Again about an hour’s sleep all night. The other thing on this car was the guy running the snack bar would come on the P. A. system about every half an hour trying to sell his snacks, drinks and food, Very Annoying. All the windows were again dirty. The bathrooms were kept a little better. This time we kept all of our bags with us. An attendant named Nina did try and keep things cleaner than the first train, she was often going around with a vacuum. The train arrived about an hour and a half late to Chicago.
     
Read 5 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by Apple Mac on 2010-07-02:
Sound like your typical government run agency, with employees who do not want to work for the high salary they make. Wait until the same government, who runs Amtrak and the Post Office, takes over the health care in this country.

Good post - you are better off flying if you have a long distance to travel.
Posted by spiderman2 on 2010-07-02:
Apple is right, just wait until the government is running healthcare!
Posted by leet60 on 2010-07-02:
Just seems odd that the OP had such a horrendous experience on the outbound trip, yet jumped right back on the train for the return trip.
Posted by spiderman2 on 2010-07-02:
I'm betting the tickets were purchased for a round trip and they weren't cheap.
Posted by Harry Patterson on 2013-03-04:
Just because airlines aren't a line item in the federal budget (like Amtrak is) doesn't mean airlines subsist without any form of government subsidy.
Close commentsAdd reply


StarStarStarEmpty StarEmpty Star
Love Hate Relationship With Amtrak
Posted by Desolationangel34 on 03/24/2013
CHICAGO-LOS ANGELES, ILLINOIS -- Here's the good, bad and ugly regarding my many trips on Amtrak, always long distance (since I had to stop flying due to an ear pressure issue)

Good: if you get a sleeper car, you are treated well by everyone working on the train it seems.

Bad: Sleeping cars will make it prohibitively expensive if you need to travel more than once a year and book quick.

Ugly: if you book coach (which still costs slightly more than a similar airline ticket for long, big city trips), be prepared to be treated like trash by most Amtrak employees. You might as well not be human. I have dealt with 10% of attendants who aren't like this (and be very thankful if you get a dreadlocked gentleman named Michael, he is awesome).

Good: food, which is included in your total if you book a sleeper, is surprisingly edible.

Bad: if you do not get a sleeper, the dining options are pretty pricey for what you get and they tend to serve you with less care (a recurring theme with Amtrak employees).

Ugly: Amtrak is ridiculously disorganized, will overfill overnight trips with seating arrangements, when you walk through the train, there are empty 2 seaters all over the place. Meanwhile, they consistently put tall guys together for days, making it very uncomfortable just because they can. And they will not rectify it because if you are traveling in coach, who cares about you.

Good: very informative about delays, which aren't their fault. Anyone who travels by train knows Amtrak doesn't own the rails and the vaunted private sector believes all goods have the right of way over people. So if you blame the government, as some commenters do, you should note the next bad. And they try to make up time in the middle, but obviously can not get ahead until the end since they can't leave stops early.

Bad: a lot of entitled jack holes seem to ride, whether it be 12 pieces of luggage guy or fall asleep on your shoulder guy.

Good: lots of great scenery. Great way to see the country. Multi city option is great.

Bad: the guest rewards program is awful. They spend more time with point gimmicks on credit cards and other shopping offers than they do on loyal travelers, which is just awful.

Ugly: I will reiterate, most of the attendants are just horrid. Watch your stuff like a hawk, because if something goes missing, they don't care at all.

Good: always had an outlet right at my seat. Makes travel easier.

Bad: get wifi and join the 21st century. Most Greyhounds have it for crying out loud.

Good: loads of legroom and carry on space. Bring some food with you if you can taking advantage of this.

Bad: pay someone to clean the bathrooms, although maybe some passengers should join civilization instead of being gross.

I could say more, but this covers the what to expect.


     
Read 8 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by saj80 on 2013-03-24:
Great post, and from my Amtrak experiences, 100% accurate.
Posted by trmn8r on 2013-03-24:
If there is plenty of legroom, I don't see why Amtrak intentionally (???) putting tall people next to each other is an issue.

Greyhounds have wifi? Cool! That almost makes me want to try go for a bus ride, with people even more gross than the ones you described. Travelling using public conveyances is an eye-opener for the uninitiated.

Your post is informative, and reminds me of a few train rides I have taken. The sleeper option is costly but definitely results in a more pleasurable experience.
Posted by Nohandle on 2013-03-24:
I have not traveled for years by rail (as a child) but it sounds like what someone would expect by plane now. At one time by air seats could be swapped after take off if there were empty ones. I have no idea now how it works now.

I've thought for a long time a trip by rail staying on the same train until I reached my destination would be just the the ticket. Perhaps not so.
Posted by Chaparrita on 2013-03-24:
Good, fair review. Better than most I've seen on this site.
Posted by Desolationangel34 on 2013-03-24:
Nohandle, for one time travel, book the roomette, you'll be very thankful. I travel too often right now for that to work price wise but when it was a 1 time expense as you sound like you want, it's well worth it.

I could have been more clear on my legroom problem. They are very strict on seat assignment for no reason, and unlike what I remember about flying, you have no choice, they do it all as you board. And anyone over 6'2 when mixed with another person for a long duration of the same build, is going to be more uncomfortable as legs take up space. But it is by far more legroom than a coach plane ticket or bus. I just don't get their unwillingness to let tall people switch to aisle seats for more than 24 hour trips when they are open. To be honest, it's truly just attendant laziness. I was on one really late trip where they discussed leaving people because one of the attendants left the seating chart in the terminal and a few paid ticket holders didn't get theirs. Outside of sleepers, they hate coach travelers (and my last coach trip cost 400 dollars, not like it was cheap).
Posted by jonthethird on 2013-03-25:
As a regular AMTRAK passenger, your review is spot on for the Southwest Chief. I ride the Zephyr and Coast Starlight regularly, and find the crews much more professional then those on the SW Chief. LA has a beautiful station, but the people there are the worst.
The BEST is the Empire Builder.
Posted by Alain on 2013-03-25:
I'll be thinking about this when I decide whether to take a plane, train or bus later this year for a quick trip, Pitt to Baltimore. Thanks for the excellent, helpful review!
Posted by Dale on 2013-08-25:
This review is informative and accurate. I am a retired Airline Pilot and I LOVE the train.

However, I would never travel if a roomette or bedroom was not available.

Perks on the sleeping cars not mentioned: You are allowed to bring your own alcohol on board. There are free mixers (water, juice and ice) at a bufette in each car.

You get reserved seating for meals. Your steward asks you what time you want to eat and calls you 15 min prior.

When buying the cheapest coach ticket you can get, and add a roomette or bedroom, 2 additional people (BR or 1 Roomette) are entitled to that same cheap fare regardless of when they book as long as they share your room...and they eat free as well...

Yes, I LOVE the train...D
Close commentsAdd reply

An Amtrak Trip You Should Know About
Posted by Dg6542 on 09/22/2008
In October of 2007, my wife and I (65 years old) began a two thousand dollar Amtrak trip in a standard roomette. We were soon subjected to stultifying high temperatures and a lack of ventilation in our 6 and-a-half by 3 and-a-half foot compartment. The unsmiling, condescending and insolent conductors professed helplessness in the face of the oppressive conditions, and when I asked one of the conductors what his name was, he immediately covered his identity badge with his hand!

We continued to object to these conditions, and finally the conductor had the train stopped, called in local marshals, and ejected my wife and I from the train in the middle of the night.

We were forced to quickly pack all of our luggage and drag our bags off the train without any assistance. We had our tickets confiscated, and were left standing in the dark around midnight, after being told that we were forever banned from Amtrak trains. However, we were not the only couple who was profoundly distressed by our Amtrak experience. When the conductor overheard me speaking to one of the marshals about this, he immediately returned our tickets to us and offered my wife and I the option of getting back on the train the following day! What was it that I told the Marshall? That approximately 12 hours before, another couple had been kicked off the train with the accompaniment of the police for complaining about the suffocating conditions!

It's one thing that Amtrak charges high prices for the honor of occupying a tiny bedroom in one of their obsolete railcars. It's another thing if in addition, the service personnel are generally rude, insulting and sadistic. The only exception to this would be in the dining car where a gratuity is expected.

My wife and I sued Amtrak for this abusive service and our abandonment in an unknown town in the middle of the night. We won with little difficulty.

It seems Amtrak has a stable of attorneys on call to take care of litigations of this type. Make sure you are prepared with adequate legal support the next time you travel Amtrak.
     
Read 5 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by ejack053824 on 2008-09-22:
No way I would ever take one of those cattle cars. Take a cruise next time...I'm sure you will enjoy that much better! :)
Posted by Anonymous on 2008-09-22:
I real life "Throw Mama From The Train"!
I'd start sending them text messages. They're quite scared of those these days.
Posted by madconsumer on 2008-09-22:
there has to be more to this than being told. people are not removed form trains for complaining about no ac.

i would like to read the court docets if this rally went to court.
Posted by oldisgood on 2008-09-23:
it seems a whole bunch of information is missing from this post.
Posted by grandma005 on 2008-09-23:
Next time ride coach seats. You will have A/C and save a lot of money.
Close commentsAdd reply

Amtrak needs a major overhaul/housecleaning
Posted by Eyrewoman on 07/23/2007
FREMONT, MICHIGAN -- I am compelled to write and relate the horrible experience we received at the hands of the Amtrak Company. In the last five years, my family and I have been frequent and preferred travelers on Amtrak. We have traveled on Amtrak on our last three cross country vacations as first class passengers. We even use the Amtrak Visa as our most used credit card. I would also like to add here that as a teacher, I was one of the biggest advocates of train travel and your company until our most recent experience.

You can review the file # 2021846 for details on our train reservations and tickets, but our trip went seriously awry almost at the very beginning of our journey. We planned to park in the long term parking in Holland Michigan and meet the Southwest Chief in Chicago. Upon pulling into the parking lot, we were immediately accosted by two women who refused to identify themselves. They were telling everyone that they could not park in the Amtrak designated lot but must move to a lot over a half mile away. The women claimed that the alternate lot was clearly identified with Amtrak signs and flags, but it was not. Afraid that we would miss the train, my husband parked the car in a completely random parking lot nearly one mile away from the Amtrak lot. Throughout our entire stay in California, we never knew if our car would be in the lot when we returned or not. The one Amtrak employee at the station would not comment about these two unidentified women who were claiming to everyone that the parking lot would be “ripped up” for remodeling in a day or two even though the parking lot looked like it was in fine condition.

The train to Chicago was canceled and busses were sent to take us to Chicago. The Amtrak employee on our bus was very nice, but he did not know where the train stations were. We were lost a few times, and the employee had to go into gas stations (in full Amtrak uniform) and ask where the train stations were. Fortunately, we arrived in time to still catch the Southwest Chief train #3 on July 6.

As I stated before, my family and I are seasoned Amtrak travelers. Our car hostess was excellent on this trip out to California. Our kids were really disappointed that Amtrak no longer employed a Native American guide for narration in the Western states or provided a movie in the lounge car. Our car hostess, however, did point out many places of interest to us. Also very disappointing on our trip to California was the major decline in the food and service of the dining car. We tried to understand paper table cloths and plastic plates as the ravages of budget cuts, but the “special” was the same “country fried steak” on both nights of the trip, and the passengers who were in the private, pulled cars treated the diner like a bar. They were given very preferential treatment to the Amtrak first class customers who only wanted to fed. We found the dining staff to be exceptionally rude to paying Amtrak customers and exceptionally accommodating to the people in the cars that were being pulled behind us.

All of the minor inconveniences pale, however, to what we experienced when our Train # 5 Southwest Chief arrived in Chicago at 9:00 p.m. - over five hours late. Once again, as seasoned Amtrak passengers, we did not worry about the delay and believed all the assurances we were given on the train that busses would be waiting to take us to our destinations or appropriate hotel accommodations would be made. Now, the nightmare begins.

When we arrived in Chicago, the customer service staff acted completely surprised and irritated by our presence. We were herded back and forth between a foyer, the ticket line, and waiting room G. Our family was sent and waited in line in three different places. The promised busses never came. Finally near midnight, we made it to a customer service employee who informed us that we were all going to be sent to a hotel in Homewood - a far south suburb which was over 40miles away. I have enclosed a review on this hotel. I grew up near this hotel and it had hourly rates when I was a child. There was no way I was going to this hotel 40 miles away from the station, after midnight, when I knew what a filthy and dangerous place it was. Because the employees would not send a bus back to this hotel until noon, anyone with a possible morning connection was basically told to like it or lump it. Especially rude throughout this entire experience was an employee with the last name Maloney. She was seriously angry when about 15 of us opted to spend the night in the station and catch morning connections rather than go to this “fleabag” motel over 40 miles away. Amtrak claimed that all Chicago hotels were filled. This was not true. Ms. Maloney said they usually put people up in Hyatt, Swisshotel and Westin. I called all three hotels that night, and they all had rooms.

Those of us who were spending the night were not given pillows or meals or even allowed in a first class lounge. Were were ushered into a filthy coach lounge with individual metal chairs that were bolted together - not conducive to sleeping. Ms. xxxxxxxx backed by an equally nasty security guard who insisted on treating us like prison inmates informed us that we had “refused” their offer of a hotel and we had better get something to eat (with our own money) in the next half hour because we were going to be confined to this room by the security guard.

Making the best of it, we found some mats that were velcroed to the wall, and we made up beds. In this group of fifteen was a crying teenage girl who we had to give money for food, other children, and a man who was traveling to his brother’s funeral and needed to be there by the next afternoon. My husband had to phone work and tell them he would miss another day - not an easy call to make when you have been on vacation for two weeks.

When we got all settled, in comes the nasty security guard and this Ms Mxxxxxxx again. In a loud voice with guard behind her, she demanded to know who had taken the mats off the walls. We explained to her that we all had, and that it was our only means of passing the night without food, pillows, blankets, and now locked bathrooms. Again she angrily insisted that we were offered a hotel that we we did not take and we were lucky they were letting us stay in this lounge. I then informed her that all of us wanted MORNING connections and would not be transported 40 miles away from the station without transportation back until noon could not go to this hotel. She then said she was going to get a manager and that we would not be permitted to use the mats.

After she strode away, the security guard told us that we were lucky we were not going to be thrown on the streets. He told us he should take us out and turn us out on the streets of Chicago and it was only by the grace of Amtrak that we were getting this lounge. My kids started crying and then he left. A few minutes later, the manager strode into the lounge, took one look at our pathetic selves that you must remember had been a train for three days before this experience. Then he strode out again without a word. Thankfully, we never saw Ms. Maloney again, but at 5 am, the security guard yelled in prison tone and fashion, “Ok, ladies and gentlemen, this lounge is opening in 5 minutes. You need to get up, put the cushions back and get out. McDonalds will be opening in 5 minutes!!!” Let me tell you, at that moment, I did not feel like someone who had paid thousands of dollars to be a first class passenger on Amtrak, my husband was missing work, my exhausted kids were sicker than dogs, I felt dirty inside and out. We cashed in our train tickets, and headed to Greyhound by cab. We slept on the floor of the Greyhound station until our bus came to take us to Michigan.

I am not writing this letter because I want anything from Amtrak, but you need to be aware of the way first class passengers were treated at the hands of your corporation. Our experience was nothing short of a nightmare but then I think what if I were elderly, or a mother traveling alone or someone like that poor terrified teenage girl with no money who spent the night in the lounge with us? What about these people? C’mon Amtrak, you can do better and you know you can….time to clean house and start being a service for people again. I am only a teacher, but I could have never treated anyone the way Ms. Maloney and the rest of that staff treated us. I could have never went home to my comfy bed knowing there were people in that stuffy, nasty lounge all night. Shame on them. Shame on them. And if you ignore this letter and do nothing about this: Shame on you.

Sincerely,

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Amtrak Guest Rewards Member #xxxxxxxxxxx

****When we arrived back in Holland, MI and hiked the mile to our car absolutely no changes had been made to where we were originally going to park in the Amtrak lot.



     
Read 12 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by firengine103 on 2007-07-23:
unbelievable
Posted by Anonymous on 2007-07-23:
Wow! Some vacation
Posted by familytravel on 2007-07-23:
This sounds miserable, and it doesn't surprise me at all Amtrak treated you all this way. I only travel for extremely short distances. I find most Amtrak staff to be downright mean and cruel to passengers. Let us know if Amtrak responds to the letter!
Posted by Starlord on 2007-07-23:
I don't knnw what happened, but my post was eaten in mid-composition. Thie person's treatment is intolerable. I have not traveled by train since I was a child, and I remember the trains as a great way to travel. I have never used Amtrak, as they did not exist when I went by train, my last two experiences with Greyhound were very similar to the OP's treament at the hands of Amtrak. I go by air or by car, and have been very satisfied. Amtrak should hang it's head in shame and learn how to treat customers. It is time all companies pick up on the fact thaqt the customer is the reason they are in business, and without the customers, they will have no business, regardless of how pretty their stores, offices or cars are. Treat your customers right, or you will find out what red ink is REALLY all about.
Posted by Anonymous on 2007-07-23:
Totaly unbelievable! what a bad vacation!
Posted by lepearso on 2007-07-23:
This is outrageous!

First of all, you should refer the matter at the Holland train station to your elected officials in Michigan. The train to Holland is sponsored by the State Dep't of Transportation.

Secondly, Amtrak has had problems in the past with the management at Chicago Union Station. Send a letter to Mr. Alex Kummant, the president of the company, and let him know how horrible this was.

Third, the decline in first class service is partially a result of congress trying to micromanage Amtrak's on-board services. Or, it could be a result of Amtrak making cuts in the wrong places. Whatever the reason, it is not acceptable.

I too am an Amtrak rider and a supporter of the train system. However, sometimes Amtrak is its own worst enemy.
Posted by Anonymous on 2007-07-24:
Admittedly the OP had a horrible experience. The Southwest Chief operates with Superliner cars. I am assuming the private cars are not Amtrak equipment. If there are private cars attached there's no way for those passengers to gain access to the Amtrak diner. Passage through Superliners are via the upper level whereas private cars are single level. There is a way to move from one level to another through what's called a Transition car but those are only used for employees and there are always locked to prevent passengers from gaining access. Also passengers in private cars are not allowed to enter the rest of the train except in emergencies. They usually carry their own food and drink. I'll agree that the food on Amtrak has really gone downhill what with budget cuts. In fact no railroad ever turned a profit on food service. Amtrak loses millions on food service every year. In all my train travel over the years only once have I experienced poor service, but never coming close to to this story.
Posted by mangomaiden on 2007-07-24:
This is one the best well-written, legitimate grievances I've seen on here. I certainly hope you take lepearso's advice and forward this onto both the management at Chicago Union Station AND Amtrak. Your experience sounds absolutely intolerable.
Posted by Ponie on 2007-07-24:
'I am only a teacher,...' Do NOT belittle yourself. You sound like the type teacher we need more of in our public school system.

This is a very well written letter and I hope Amtrak responds favorably to you.
Posted by Anonymous on 2007-07-24:
Over at http://discuss.amtraktrains.com/index.php?showtopic=17663
There a multi page discussion on the subject as posted here. No, I did not originate it there.
Posted by Dakota17 on 2007-08-03:
I think that I had also met your Ms. XXXX while we were trying to work out a hotel/bus solution after missing our connection as well. I thought she was just having a bad day when we met her. She is the part of the reason I sat down to write a complaint letter to Amtrak. I did want to let you know, not that this helps at all, that they did redo both the overflow lot and the main Amtrak lot in Holland. It only took them about four days to do it but anyone gone over that time period had to park in the old Pietro's parking lot. Not that it changes how they handled the situation or anything, just for info. We also had to park in the Pietro's lot and I can understand how anyone that's not from around here might be hesitant to do so. Thanks for your post. It was very well written.
Posted by Leave Early and Walk on 2007-08-18:
Maybe politics has no place in this discussion or perhaps it does. I last rode the Amtrak "Coast Starlight" in 2001 from Portland to Seattle. Parlour (what genius changed the spelling from "parlor")Car was nice; dining car a joke for someone who's old enough to remember the Santa Fe "Super Chief". No more. Amtrak is part of a huge regression in travel comfort in the U.S. and abroad.

Despite high gas prices, congestion, global warming and lord knows what other aggrevations, George Bush hasn't had a clue. I wish we could send him back to Texas when his term is up via Amtrak in coach. Bottom line is that it's time for whomever takes over to chuck the whole organization and start over.

No public carrying passenger railroad in the world makes money. Some trains will and do, but for a whole system, no. We need an independent body, legislation with teeth, and someone who understands that they are selling a service. Certainly a number of the freight railroads have let their tracks go to hell, constantly delay Amtrak and skirt around their contracts.

Until we have a rational national transportation policy we're doomed to more of the same. Let's see, the highway bridges are collapsing, airline service and reliability is a disgrace, Greyhound is real "dog", rail travel stinks. Now you understand my "handle". The market is there for rail travel and moving freight off over crowded highways to upgraded railroads is not only cost effective, but helps cut down on global warming.

Will we every wise up? One hopes, and by the way before you gang up on me for "Bush Bashing" I'm a registered Republican. Stand up, speak out and don't take it any more. If you can afford it with our lousy exchange rate, get to France and take the TGV. It is possible to get somewhere with reasonable speed, great comfort and good, if a bit expensive, dining. Am I jealous? You bet!
Close commentsAdd reply


Amtrak Texas Eagle Is A Joke!
Posted by Mike3797 on 04/11/2010
Amtrak Texas eagle is a complete joke, train both ways were hours late, food was terrible, staff were typical government employees, lazy with attitude. Train smelled of chemical toilet, I spent more than a plane fare to try the train and never again! I am a veteran but the only way to get the veterans fare was to join a for profit organization called "veterans advantage" for $60. dollars.

What a joke, don't do me any favors! We should stop funding this waste! of course it is governments job to waste our money isn't it?
     
Read 1 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by wendy on 2013-08-01:
July 13, 2013: I purchased a roomette for myself. I have a disability and thought that a 14 hr. trip would be easier for me if I could lay down. I was not assisted to my roomette, nor did my car attendant introduce himself to me. Infact I did not even know there was a car attendant for several hours. As I began to try to make a bed out of my 2 sets, which caused me a great deal of pain!!! I began to notice the smell of raw sewerage!!! This DISGUSTING smell only got worse every 15-20 mins. when my entire room would become engulfed by a huge gush of the smell of raw sewerage!!!! I pleaded with the conductore to move me from the roomette to another. He said that he could not as that later on when we arrive in Housto Tx. more people would be getting on board. I had to spend my entire journey from New Orleans La. to San Antonio Tx. in a car that smelled worse then a port-o-john in mid summer. The man who was my car attendant, was very rude!!! The people in the dining car were also very rude!!! This was not just a bad experince. This was a Nightmare!!! Ispent most of the time in my roomette, with my face covered with a scarf, crying, and wishing that I could jump from the train!!! This was peppered w/ trips to a very tiny bathroom to vomit, literally!!! Customer service was not much help. They offered a portion of 1 trip next time. I don't think there will be another time!!!
Close commentsAdd reply

A Nice Alternative
Posted by Obsfucation on 12/07/2010
Auto Train Route
Auto Train Route
A long planned trip to Disney World with the grandkids was scheduled for the week following Thanksgiving. When I was making the travel arrangements, I was dreading the airport hassles, with visions of my 5 year old grandson being strip searched. (I think we all saw that video).

Then I remembered the Auto Train. We did this trip a few times when our own kids were small, and liked it then.

It's even better now. The train departs from Lorton VA, so we drove down from Boston the day before, and spent the time on a quick DC tour. You board the train at 3 pm, and at the same time your car is loaded onto a car carrier.

The train pulls out at 4, and at 5 they have the first seating for dinner in the dining car. On the outbound trip I had chicken marsala, wine and cheesecake. Returning it was braised beef, more wine and a decadent brownie a la mode. In general, the conductor and support staff are very cordial and friendly, and took time out to socialize with the kids.

In the evening they run a movie in the lounge car, and put out cookies and snacks. After that, I was ready to recline my seat and close the shades. There are sleeper cars available, but I find the regular seats just fine. I didn't even need the bar car ahead of time to ensure a good sleep.

In the morning there is a Continental breakfast in the dining car. At 9 am the train rolls into Sanford FL, where they unload your car and you have a quick hop to WDW.

Perhaps the best thing is because you have your won car, you can pack whatever you want. No luggage to haul around, you just take what you need onto the train with you. ( i.e. your toothbrush) Since you never know what to expect at this time of year, we packed both summer and cool weather clothing.

The kids got a huge kick out of riding and sleeping on a train, and the cost (for 5 of us) was slightly less that airfare would have been. It was a win-win.

I think I am going to consider taking a train next time I vacation, it was a very pleasant alternative. I'd love to see them give the airlines a run for their money.
     
Read 22 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by Anonymous on 2010-12-07:
Nice review Obs, glad you and your family had such a good time.
Posted by Slimjim on 2010-12-07:
I've played around with the idea of taking this train when going to Florida for years. One time we'll have to try it.
Posted by MRM on 2010-12-07:
I didnt know the train takes that route. Thanks for the tidbit!
Posted by momsey on 2010-12-07:
That's awesome. Definitely something to keep in mind a few years down the road when we're ready to start hitting Disney!
Posted by werelucky on 2010-12-07:
Just remember, it's a 24 hour slow train ride, and it's not always on time.
Posted by Anonymous on 2010-12-07:
I like a nice, long, slow ride. Not so sure about a train though.
Posted by MRM on 2010-12-07:
How much is the train ride and how long was the trip?
Posted by madconsumer on 2010-12-07:
i love traveling by train. not the fastest way to get there, but oh so comfortable.

very helpful.
Posted by Obsfucation on 2010-12-07:
We paid a bit less than $1,200 for five people and our car. (r/t) The train leaves around 4 pm, and arrives around 9 the next morning.
Posted by madconsumer on 2010-12-07:
obs, just remeber to tell everyone if they wanted a ptivate room, it adds 300-400 more per person!

but this also includes meals and prefered dinning time, and a private valet!!
Posted by jktshff1 on 2010-12-07:
great post thanks
Posted by Skye on 2010-12-07:
Great review!

Posted by Nohandle on 2010-12-07:
I've not been on a train since I was a small child. On my last trip, I recall my parents putting me on one to go to summer camp. I would love to travel by rail now. I'm weary of airlines and heaven forbid the bus but there aren't too many options anymore other than driving. It's a shame rail travel is not available in many areas. If you've never been on a train for a trip, not a morning commute, honestly you've missed something enjoyable.
Posted by momsey on 2010-12-07:
That's not a bad price!
Posted by Obsfucation on 2010-12-07:
MadC... there are 3 types of rooms. $190 (sleeps two), $547 (sleeps 4), and $415 (sleeps 2, has toilet and shower. The room rate isn't per person, it's per room.

Since the regular seating is similar to (actually better than) airline first class seats, I can't see a real reason to spend that kind of money for an overnight trip.
Posted by Anonymous on 2010-12-07:
There is a dinner train here, good food and great scenery.
Posted by 3marliz on 2010-12-09:
My family and I always wanted to try the train. Three years ago was the first and last time. The first night the sleeper room we had reserved was unavailable. (We still paid for it by the way.)

We missed a meal because the train ran late to one of it's stops; we were not allowed to dine at a stop and so tough luck, we missed the meal.

They ran out of food the last day and the only thing to eat for our meal in the fancy dining car was Mac and Cheese.

The train was delayed and instead of phoning ahead to let the next station know we would be ten minutes late, the last train left. We waited two hours for a van to arrive and cram the passengers in to drive us the last few hours of the trip.

We talked to some people who loved taking the train and found out (too late) that the crews on different runs were different and those in the know timed their departure to be on the trains with good crews.

Maybe it's different now but it wouldn't hurt if you are taking Amtrack, to talk to some regulars at the station find out if there is still a big difference between the trains.

I thought of posting this as a review, but so much time has passed it seemed better to post it as a comment that might help others have a better trip.
Posted by ok4now on 2010-12-10:
Good post. Unless you are really pressed for time & need to fly this is the way to go. Excellent point about avoiding the airport screening & body scans. Plus they have a dining car instead of a bag of peanuts provided by the airlines. My only reservation from talking to friends who have used this is the possible damage to your car. Apparently they aren't real careful and this has generated many damage complaints. With the common $500 deductible the customer may have to absorb any potential damage out of pocket. Aside from this the train is definitely the way to go.
Posted by lorrwill on 2010-12-12:
Wow was your experience spectacularly different than mine.

The last time I rode Amtrak I had to stand almost the entire trip because I could not find a place to sit down. People were taking up 2 or 3 seats with their belongings and the porters told me tough luck.

Amtrak's customer service depends privilege people like me don't have.
Posted by Alain on 2011-01-06:
Just read this, Obsfucation. Good review and just the type of airport alternative I'm considering these days! Maybe it's time I gave Amtrak a try again even if it does take a little more time!
Posted by ms millie on 2011-01-14:
It's refreshing to see such a positive review. So many people use these sites to "bash" a company instead of feeling compelled to write when something wonderful happens. I enjoyed reading your post!
Posted by canucks1 on 2011-03-24:
CHEAPER TO FLY!
Close commentsAdd reply

StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty Star
Train Service Sucks!!
Posted by Ispyder on 04/28/2012
CENTRALIA, ILLINOIS -- I arrived at the train station in Centrailia, IL 3 hours before the train was scheduled to depart. The train ended up being almost an hour late with no way of knowing exactly when it would show up. Finally, when it did arrive, it slowed down, stopped, the conductor threw some bags off, a couple passengers departed, and the train took off. I barely had time to get out of the car I was waiting in before the train was already on its way out.

They didn't even check to see if a passenger was supposed to get on the train and sure as hell didn't wait for me as I ran towards the tracks. It's utter bull crap. Even the station conductor, who knew I was there waiting, failed to tell me prior to the train's arrival that if the train is running late and you're not waiting on the platform, they will leave without you.

No signs were posted or anything listed on the website that stated you must be on the platform waiting if the train is running late. The website also suggested that the train has a load and unload time of about 5 minutes. This train had come and gone within a minute.

And besides all that crap, it makes it even worse that they expect you to stand on the platform and wait for a late train, not knowing when the hell it's going to show up, in the freezing cold at 1 in the morning in the middle of a shady side of town by yourself.

Their service sucks, their staff are douche bags, and the idea that trains are supposed to be on time is a bull crap lie.

The best way I can put it: if you're new to train travel, make sure you can read minds.
     
Read 3 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by Notatrainfreak on 2012-04-28:
AMTRAK offers multiple way of checking train status. You can go online, use a smartphone app or simply call their reservations number for automated service. If a train, or a bus is running late, they don't hang around. Unload and load - then gone. The web site does not show a scheduled 5 minute stop. In fact Centraila is a 'flag' stop which means if they don't see you they don't know you are there.

BTW, what station conductor are you referring to? Centraila is an unstaffed station. No ticket office, just an enclosed waiting area.
Posted by copper_works_ on 2012-04-28:
Maybe it was some freaky guy pretending to be a conductor.
Posted by jonthethird on 2012-04-28:
AMTRAK is indeed a different way to travel. The trains are subject to delays due to track work, traffic, etc as AMTRAK does not own the rails. It is still a much more relaxing way to travel
Close commentsAdd reply

Amtrak Stinks - Literally
Posted by Analilia on 01/12/2009
I recently emailed Amtrak Customer Service the following complaint regarding my train travel experience:

"I'd like to share with you my recent experience traveling from NY to LA on Amtrak. When traveling coach, I do expect a certain amount of discomfort and I plan accordingly. However, there are a number of things Amtrak might consider to create a more pleasant trip for coach passengers.

1) Smoking: Smokers are addicts and will continue, despite threats to put them off the train, to smoke in the bathrooms and changing rooms. The smell from this permeates the entire train car and does not go away. Please make a real effort to create a solution that meets the needs of your smoking and non-smoking passengers. Smokers are not going away and they don't care about kids, people with allergies, or the general health of anyone else.

2) Air Quality: We had the unfortunate experience of several drunken passengers who had both stomach and bowel problems. For the last 30 hours of our trip, the train car smelled like a port-a-potty. Several passengers had to leave the car as the smell was overwhelming. I'm not sure how to solve this, but ventilation changes or a different cleaning and/or toilet solution might help.

3) Employee Morale: In general I found the train personnel to be on the discourteous side. Perhaps it was a bad journey for everyone, but passengers look to the staff to help make it better. I observed staff giving curt responses, speaking in disrespectful tone of voice, and flat-out ignoring passengers.

I do enjoy riding the train, much more than flying. But after this last trip I am not likely to choose Amtrak. All my friends have now heard about my experience and that kind of word-of-mouth is not the marketing that will bring you new passengers. Thank you for your time."

I received a reply which in itself barely addressed my experience or gave any hint of the company's desire or intention to create better travel experiences. In addition, when I replied with the information requested in their email to me, the Amtrak email server did not process my reply and returned my email as 'undeliverable.' Here is Amtrak's reply to my complaint:

"Thank you for your email.

In order for us to document your concerns and suggestions correctly, and to provide the right train manager the information we are asking you to attach your reservation number or travel dates to this email.

Once we have that information we will file a report on your behalf to the responsible managers.

We do apologize for your trip being less then satisfactory and we appreciate your comments.

Regards,

Amtrak Customer Relations"
     
Read 3 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by Anonymous on 2009-01-12:
Using email only generates the generic response you got. You really need to speak with someone at AMTRAK.
Posted by Ben There on 2009-01-12:
"But after this last trip I am not likely to choose Amtrak"... Not really any other train options out there in the USA...
Posted by Analilia on 2009-01-15:
As to other choices, I'll just go back to driving or flying.
Close commentsAdd reply


Cleanliness of passenger train
Posted by Susanzink199053 on 01/01/2012
NEW YORK TO CINCINNATI TRAIN, KENTUCKY -- AmTrak passenger train Cardinal train 51 from New York to Cincinnati was dirty. Several sitings of roaches in Coach class, had to ride train for 18 hours worried about roaches. Bathrooms were also stinky and dirty, no toilet paper for awhile and urine on the floor. When conductor told about sitings of roaches, she replied "just stomp on them." Food service, sub-par, freezer froze up, so only one choice in seated/waited on dining, on other side of Cafe car, only few choices of food due to running low on choices, everything from microwave, poor planning when train was completely full. Poor customer services. Unless these problem are rectified, I will never ride the AmTrak train again.
     
Read 3 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by MRM on 2012-01-01:
18 hours in a confined space is torture.
Posted by madconsumer on 2012-01-02:
i enjoy traveling by train, even long trips. sadly, the stocking is only done at certain stops. sometimes they do run out of things.

in all my trips, i have never seen roaches on any train.
Posted by jonthethird on 2012-01-02:
The only roaches I have ever seen on Amtrak were back in the coach and they were two legged kind. Yes, it is a shame that, due to limited budgets, the trains are not serviced more often. I travel frequently on Amtrak, always in a sleeper though.
Close commentsAdd reply

StarStarStarEmpty StarEmpty Star
It's Not Florida, but the Sun's in My Face
Posted by Aromac1ous on 12/25/2013
BALTIMORE, MARYLAND -- This seems like such a petty complaint after reading another reviewers remarks.

I recently boarded a train in Baltimore and was so annoyed to find there was no way to block the southern exposure effect coming through my window. My suggestion--either install window shades on this particular route or discount the sunny seats.

Some people suffer from disorders that are worsened by too much light.
     
Read 1 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by FoDaddy19 on 2013-12-27:
Was it possible to simply move to another unoccupied seat?
Close commentsAdd reply

Top of Page | Next Page >