Preview Review

Next Review

Progressive Auto Insurance Consumer Reviews - Page 5

Most Popular | Newest | More Options >
More filter options:
Major Problems With a Minor Claim
By -

I am a 15+ year customer of Progressive with no tickets, accidents, and I have never made a claim. A few weeks ago someone parked next to me in a parking lot in an SUV opened their tailgate causing their spare tire carrier to swing around and the tire put a little dent in my fender. Total damage: around $800. I took a week off from work to get it fixed. The claim problems began when claim representative Stephanie declared this was a COLLISION and not a comp claim, thereby increasing my deductible from $250 to $500 even though the paint was unscratched in and around the dent.

When I tried to argue the point, she called me a liar and accused me of attempting to defraud her of the $250 difference! Then, after I got my estimates and decided on a body shop, Progressive's estimator didn't show up as promised for several days causing me to have to pay a week's worth of additional rental car fees to get to work.

This tiny claim was a nightmare. Claim Rep Stephanie was a heavy handed unprofessional bully whose primary motivation was obviously geared more toward her 'no claim payout' bonus check than to helping me get back on the road. For 15 years Progressive was great at accepting my payments. But when it finally came time to make a very small claim, the friendly demeanor was gone. Never again.

Progressive? Never again
By -

My son and I both had our trucks vandalized a few weeks ago; we both had 2 tires slashed by neighborhood punks. I have State Farm, my son has Progressive. The Progressive agent just left our house (after taking almost 4 weeks to get here), and told us my son would be getting nothing back from his claim, because the cost of buying tires IN THE SAME CONDITION AS THE OTHER 2 ALREADY ON THE TRUCK, was less that his $500 deductible. They wanted us to buy USED tires to replace the slashed ones, which were less than 1 year old. He had already bought 2 new tires because Progressive told him not to do anything until the agent saw and evaluated his slashed ones.

So he was expected to sit and wait 4 weeks waiting for the adjuster to show up before he could use his truck! His couldn't wait, of course, and his cost for 2 new tires was $1200. He had a $500 deductible, and Progressive says they will pay nothing. I my State Farm agent the day we found the slashed tires, and they told me to go buy 2 NEW tires and send them the invoice by fax. I had a check in 4 days, for the full amount of the tires, minus my $250 deductible. Progressive? How about renaming them Regressive! State Farm never even sent someone to examine the tires. Is State Farm more expensive than Progressive? Not when Progressive refuses to pay their claims!

Progressive Won't Pay Fair Value
By -

RANCHO CORDOVA, CALIFORNIA -- I have been in an accident. I am fine, but my car was rear-ended by a non-insured driver. My car is a 1991 Ford Mustang 5.0 convertible, it has very low miles (53K). I have had this car for over 17 years, and it's like a child to me, it had been in storage for 6-7 years, which explains the low miles and the good condition. The car had $4300 damage in the accident, I had gotten several official estimates.

The car is not in perfect condition, but I would consider it in good condition for the age of the vehicle. I have over the last few years been restoring it in my spare time. I bought replacement (original Ford parts) for the bumper, fenders, seats, carpet. The vinyl top has been replaced, the transmission rebuilt. It had been maintenanced regularly. There was some additional trim work to be completed, and then all it needed was painted. The car then would be in near excellent condition.

My issue is that Progressive Insurance will only pay me $2400 and they keep my car, or pay me $1800 and I can keep my car. I only want my car fixed. They say the value of the car is less than the repair cost. But they have not shown me their research where I can get the exact same condition car for $2400. Or I could take their money and buy one, which in reality, I would be afraid to do, as I know the history and care I have given my own car. I don't want to have my car replaced with someone else's problem car.

Millar Agency And Progressive Insurance, They Will Get You In A Claim!
By -

LAKE OSWEGO, OREGON -- I purchased an RV and planned to live in it full time. I wanted to be fully covered so I called many companies to make sure I got the right insurance. I spoke with ** 3 different times for over 1 hour total. He promised me that he knew how to insure a full-timer. I told him everything we had in the RV to make sure we were covered. He had me purchase an additional $10,000 Full Replacement Cost coverage for my computer and ham radio equipment on top of the full coverage policy. I believed him.

6 months after I purchased the Progressive policy from them, I was parked next to a building that took a lightning strike. The adjuster came out to look over all our ruined electronics. I had $6000 worth of damage. I was glad I had purchased the extra insurance. But WAIT! $10,000 FULL REPLACEMENT COST does not mean $10,000 full replacement cost. It ONLY means UP TO $2,500 per category AND It only means UP TO $1000 per item!! What a surprise. They would only pay me $3000 for the $6000 in damage no matter that I paid for FULL replacement cost.

This company is a rip off either because they don't know how to insure people or they are dishonest about it. I wanted to make sure I was covered. ** did not take care of me. They said there was nothing they could do and I should buy more coverage in the future. Buyer beware.

Progressive Insurance Update
By -

WOODBRIDGE, VIRGINIA -- I have been posting about how bad Progressive is screwing its customer base. Well here's an update. After suing them and after four years I find out they have a lifetime warranty on their work. I called them and told them about the terrible work they did on our truck and they said bring it in. Well guess what all the complaints and bull they repainted it, straightened the door and fixed the water leak in the rear door.

All this after they told a judge in court that all repairs were done correctly than to fix it four years later. Beware - Progressive like most insurance companies will scam you. I'm not just saying this - it is a fact. Most people say "oh! I've never had a problem with mine." Wait until you get hit and if you don't know repairs. You only think it's right. Got news for you... wrong!!! Please excuse my grammar.

Travel Trailer Insurance
By -

SAN ANGELO, TEXAS -- I've had RV insurance for about four years on a travel trailer parked on my ranch property in West Texas. Last summer when I went down the skylight was broken and the kitchen had flooded. I replaced the skylight and resealed all the roof seams. There have been no leaks since then. Now the ceiling is starting to separate, the floor is spongy and the tiles are coming up. I called Progressive, they sent a letter immediately calling my attention to some language in the policy about maintenance and leakage. They also sent me a certified letter with the same information.

When I talked to the adjusted from the San Angelo office he told me he would come look at it, but he has looked at over 100 trailers recently and has not paid a claim yet. I took the day off work and drove out to meet him. He took a lot of pictures and said that even though I couldn't find the receipt, he could tell it was a new skylight and that damage from broken skylight is covered. He said he would not make the decision but his supervisor would call me next week.

I got a letter from him post marked the same day (he left my place at 11:30 am and his office is 140 miles away, do the math) with the exact same verbiage as the other two letters, except he denied the claim. These guys had their mind made up not to pay this claim as soon as I called. This company is a rip-off. They have low rates because they don't pay claims and they brag about it!

Unhappy with service I received
By -

READING, PENNSYLVANIA -- I was rear ended by a man who has Progressive Auto Ins. He did not even report the accident to his ins, I had to. I had 6 witnesses including a Federal Fugitive Recovery Agent!!! It was his fault 100%. I am getting the runaround with Progressive on the repairs to my car!

The insurance adjuster is claiming my bumper can be repaired. My repairman at the dealer where I bought my car is telling me it cannot be repaired and expected to last any amount of time it needs to be replaced!!! The ins adjuster pretty much told me the dealer will lie about needing new parts just to get more money!!

I am going to believe my mechanic before I believe some adjuster. They just don't want to pay!! The difference is like $100!!! I am so irritated with this company, I am thinking of contacting a manager or someone other than this adjuster. Don't ever get into accident with someone who has Progressive. YOU WON'T BE HAPPY WITH THE WAY YOU ARE TREATED!!!

Unauthorized Withdrawal of funds... Considering Civil Charges Against Progressive...
By -

HARRISBURG, PENNSYLVANIA -- About 3 weeks ago, I noticed that Progressive drew $490.00 from my account when they are only authorized $64.60/month. Upon calling for a week straight to get to the bottom of this error and come to a conclusion as to why this was done, I found myself making no progress in resolving this issue. I finally was able to speak with a supervisor about this situation.

Apparently, someone with Progressive added my (non-license holding) fiancée to my policy (we use her checking account for payment) without any prior commitment and/or authorization. The supervisor promised me the entire amount of $490.00 back as well as the $60.00 in overdrafts from the bank within 3 business days.

I thought that I had straightened this entire mess out only to find out that Progressive put the money back into the account with a 3 day hold period which caused us to bounce 1 more check and another $30.00… We noticed that another $218.00 had been withdrawn from our account once again WITHOUT authorization! I have been trying to contact the Supervisor that I had previously talked with for about 4 days now with no callback… I have left 3 messages.

I am seriously considering filing a Civil complaint and taking Progressive to court. They have also managed to run our name with our bank through the mud due to the now (running) total of overdraft fee's creeping up on $120.00 within a period of 3 and a half weeks. I don't know what more to do about this. MY ADVICE to you… DO NOT drive with Progressive insurance!!! They don't seem to know what is going on in their own business…

Motorcycle Insurance
By -

TENNESSEE -- I recently had a motorcycle accident in which I struck a deer. The insurance company told me that my Honda GoldWing was a total loss. I had just bought this 1998 GoldWing about a month ago. It had a rebuilt title. I paid 8,000 dollars for it because it was in great shape and only had 48,000 miles on it. It handled and ran great, better than most used GoldWings that I had seen.

Progressive calls me and tells me that since it had a rebuilt title that they would only give me 5,000 for my loss. The fact that the GoldWing was rebuilt should not make any difference. It was in better shape than most used ones. As far as I'm concerned they suck. Do not get insurance from them. I also do not think that it is a total loss. They want to send it to a salvage yard and get money from them that should be given to me. They said that if I wanted the motorcycle that they would deduct the amount of salvage from what they were giving me. What crooks!

Get a Lawyer!
By -

SACRAMENTO, CALIFORNIA -- In late February of 2006 I was rear ended by a driver who was covered by Progressive Insurance. The woman who hit me admitted that she was at fault and we each filed claim regarding the incident. As a result of the accident I was injured and required therapy to treat these injuries.

At this time I have completed my therapy sessions and have amassed over $2,100 in medical bills as a result. Progressive Insurance is stating that they are only going to pay for the first 6-8 weeks of medical bills and are offering me a little over $1,300 because they claim that "soft tissue damage heals in 6-8 weeks". They do not care that a medical professional deemed it necessary for my treatments to continue beyond their arbitrary time frame.

In addition, the agent assigned to this claim literally adds insult to injury. Whenever I speak with her she is rude, condescending, talks over me, cuts me off and refuses to allow me to speak with her supervisor. Whenever I ask to speak with her supervisor she asks why and I let her know that what she is offering me is unsatisfactory and I want to discuss the claim with her supervisor. The agent tells me that's what she is there for. It's a maddening circle.

At this point, in order for my medical bills to be paid in full I will have to consult an attorney to bring a lawsuit against the woman who hit me as well as Progressive Insurance, and as everyone knows bringing a lawyer to the table will drive up the settlement amount exponentially... it would be much more economical on behalf of Progressive Insurance to pay out the additional $800 than to have this become a lawsuit.

But, the impression I get from my personal experience as well as from reading reviews on this site as well as others is that Progressive Insurance doesn't give a damn about people. All they care about is their bottom line. Understandably, they are in business to make money, but the idea that the victim of one of their insured should be left with $800 in medical bills is absolutely ludicrous.

On their website, Progressive Insurance boasts about their extensive art collection that is housed at all of their facilities in addition to their corporate office. I find it admirable that this company would support the arts, after all I am an artisan myself, but before they purchase their next piece they should take care of those who are injured at the hands of their insured.

If I am ever again hit by a driver who is insured through Progressive I will take the following actions: Call the police for an accident report, Call for an ambulance to the emergency room regardless of how I feel at the time of the incident, GET A LAWYER to talk to Progressive Insurance on my behalf. I will NOT be bullied by another one of their representatives again.

This is my second complaint against this company regarding this claim, although it is my first "public" one. Previously I complained to my state's Insurance Commissioner's office. Their response was to speak with the claim adjustors manager. I received a letter from the manager and left her voicemails in response, but never received a single return call from the manager.

I will be following up this commentary with the following: Addressing this issue on the "contact us" page of Progressives website, repeating this entry on every site such as this one that I can find, blogging about it extensively on my personal blog, making another complaint to my state Insurance Commissioner's office since the manager is being completely unresponsive.

If you are a customer of Progressive Insurance, or considering becoming one, you may want to think about investing in prepaid legal assistance because if you were to be found at fault in an accident and people were injured you could very likely be sued because Progressive will not pay out full medical costs of those who are injured.

Top of Page | Next Page >

Progressive Auto Insurance Rating:
Star Half star Empty star Empty star Empty star
1.3 out of 5, based on 38 ratings and
121 reviews & complaints.
Contact Information:
Progressive Auto Insurance
6300 Wilson Mills Road
Mayfield Village, OH 44143
440-461-5000 (ph)
Compare Auto Insurance Companies