Bedford Cheese Shop and P&H Soda Co Complaint - Bedford Cheese Shop and P&H Soda Co Complaints – Sells Out of Date - Stale Soda Syrup

Review by anthony55 on 2011-06-21
BROOKLYN, NEW YORK -- Last week I purchased 4 bottles of pnhsodaandsyrupinc.com from
Bedford Cheese Shop for $58.00

My wife wanted a soda treat, but the trick was on her.

The syrup was stale, rancid, and disgusting.

Bedford Cheese Shop refused a refund and said to call the manufacture pnh soda and syrup.

Spoke to the owner Anton Nocito a condescending wise ass, said he didn't sell us the soda and we should take it up with Bedford Cheese Shop.

This fly by night operator, who lacks a 4 year college degree sells defective syrup products load with sugar concentration and intestinal bacteria.

read this review from a doctor that lab tested the pnh soda and syrup;
http://messages. finance. Yahoo.com/Stocks_%28A_to_Z%29/Stocks_T/threadview?m=tm&bn=10352&tid=141091&mid=141091&tof=1&frt=2

I'm surprise Martha Stweart lent her name to this product. But what do you expect from an ex con.

I lost my money, and my wife and I suffered 3 days of the runs!

Be safe and smart; stay away from pnhsodaandsyrupinc.com until they are FDA approved and inspected.

Thank you,
Anthony Tizzi
Company Response on 07/13/2011:
Dear Anthony Tizzi, Judith Weigel, Rivernos, Roger Whitlock, Mica, Sandra Pools, Judith676 or whatever name you’re choosing to go by this week,

I would like to respond to all of your accusations with proof so that it’s clear that you are simply slandering me under various names, on multiple websites:


To start with, we are not a “ghost” company as you have stated. We are licensed by the Department of Agriculture and Markets and do hold a 20-C license that currently hangs on the wall of the commercial kitchen that we work out of. The address is:

1053 Manhattan Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11222.

You are more then welcome to stop by and see the license any time I’m there.

You can actually see me working in the space in the following video here:


If you watch the video you’ll see me speak about how I think soda should be a treat, not something you drink everyday. You will also see that I use natural ingredients. Nothing is artificial or hidden.

Our soda syrups are also tested and approved by the NECFE at Cornell University in Geneva, NY.


You claimed that we do not list our address anywhere but if you had purchased a bottle of our soda syrup you would see that it is clearly printed on the label, right next to our ingredients. This is a requirement by the government before we sell any products to our consumers. You can see it by clicking the following link:


You claim that we are a fly-by-night, transient street vendor. We do sell at various local markets. We are insured and licensed to do so. The market that we frequent the most is New Amsterdam Market. Hardly what any New Yorker would consider transient.


This market is dedicated to preserving some of New York’s history. We sell at this market with the hopes of helping it become a permanent year around market like the ones in San Francisco or London. We also do these markets because it helps promote our brand, a brand that I stand behind fully.

P&H Soda Co. has developed a following over the past year and a half. Do you think the following publications would or any other accredited publication would write someone up that was considered a “ghost” or fake?:

New York Times:



Martha Stewart:

Time Out New York:


New York Magazine:

Wall Street Journal:

You are correct about me not graduating from college. I chose to go into the Air Force instead. During that time I fought in our first Gulf War. I was honorably discharged after 4 years of service. I then went into butchering for 6 year and attended The French Culinary Institute graduating on 4-13-99. I’m sure if you contact the school you will be able to find out that I graduated in the top of my class.

New York Campus 888.324.2433

I’m glad you found a copy of my resume online. You linked to it in some of your comments. If you’ll notice, I worked for some of the top restaurateurs and chefs in NY. Google the restaurants and you will see that some are three star restaurants. Your screen snap of my resume “accidentally” cut off the education portion so I’ve linked to the actual website here:


I did hold a number of positions, some of them at the same time. They were all a learning experience. Had I just worked at one place for ten years I would not have been able to learn everything I learned.

I would like to thank you for following myself and my company P&H Soda Co. If you have any further questions or comments, please feel free to contact me anytime.

Anton Nocito
P&H Soda Co.
Comments:16 Replies - Latest reply on 2013-07-21
Posted by Anonymous on 2011-07-12:
Posted by Old Timer on 2011-07-12:
Ript, I do believe P&H Soda won this one with his response over at the CB.
Posted by Anonymous on 2011-07-12:
Indeed OT, Anton presented his case and himself well.
Posted by raven2010 on 2011-07-12:
hasnt several versions of this complaint shown up here, on PFB and complaintsboard?
Posted by Anonymous on 2011-07-12:
I'll take your word for it raven. Anton, the owner of P&H says there is only one complaint about his company on CB posted by this same OP.
Posted by T on 2011-07-12:
What's a "PFB"? Sounds perverted.
Posted by madconsumer on 2011-07-12:
pfb, planet feed back.

the same site where several of our members used to reign.
Posted by Old Timer on 2011-07-12:
Thought it was: Planet Feed Bag?
Posted by raven2010 on 2011-07-12:
google this phrase: "p&h soda complaint" I count no less than TEN websites this complaint (or a version thereof) was filed at.
Posted by madconsumer on 2011-07-12:
lol Old Timer, depends on who i am talking to.
Posted by madconsumer on 2011-07-12:
but does it count if they are all copy and paste of each other?
Posted by raven2010 on 2011-07-12:
Here is a word for word of one of the versions on six sites. SOMEONE is on a major mission

Posted by Old Timer on 2011-07-12:
Guess Anthony Tizzi is not the kind of chap you want to piss off.
Posted by Anonymous on 2011-07-12:
I just passed this info off to Anton raven, thanks.
Posted by raven2010 on 2011-07-12:
Posted by KimLnyc on 2013-07-21:
Forget about his qualifications and his connections ... he's a miserable person and his soda sucks!

Do not waste your money on this garbage. It's overpriced anyway!

Your Name:
(displayed with your comment)
Your E-mail:

Your Experience/Advice:
Check spelling

By clicking submit you agree that you have read and accept the Terms of Service & Privacy Policy.

Note: All comments are reviewed by a moderator before being published. Please be sure to read our guidelines before commenting.