Review by MSCANTBEWRONG on 2008-04-24
Airlines win big on those who overpack
Stop lugging your luggage, and say 'no thanks' to extra baggage fees
By George Hobica
updated 12:49 p.m. ET, Tues., April. 22, 2008
Whether traveling for business or pleasure, airline passengers might want to think twice about how much they bring along for the ride, starting next month.

Five of the seven major U.S. airlines (Continental, Delta, Northwest, United, and US Air) plan to charge most customers $25 each way to check a second bag starting May 5. Of the largest carriers, only American and Southwest have decided not to go along — for now. Airtran is adding a $10 second bag fee for travel on or after May 15. Spirit Airlines already had a $10 fee if paid online, or $20 at the airport.

But the new fees do not apply to all passengers, advises Those buying first-class or business-class tickets, or flying on frequent flier awards in those classes, will typically be exempt, as will frequent-flier program members who have achieved upper tiers with their airlines (such as United Mileage Plus Premier customers). Military personnel flying “with orders” are off the hook.

These fees are in addition to those for excess, oversized and overweight bags, so a passenger traveling on United, for example, with three checked bags weighing 50 pounds or less will be charged $25 for the second but $100 for the third.

But if any of the three bags tips the scale at 51 pounds or more, overweight charges of an additional $100 per bag, each way, kick in. So unless otherwise exempt, a passenger flying round-trip on United with three bags weighing just a pound over the 50-pound limit would be charged $200 for the first ($100 overweight fee each way), $250 for the second (second bag fee of $25 times two plus overweight fee of $100 times two), and $400 for the third (a $100 third bag fee times two plus a $100 overweight fee times two), for a total — fasten your seat belts — of $850.

Keep in mind that these are domestic fees, and international charges may be higher, depending on destination.

A better way
There must be a better way, and there is: UPS, US Postal Service, or FedEx. Flying from your home in Manhattan to a convention in Long Beach? UPS will send your 51 pounds of trade-show samples each way for $59.34, when last checked at, with four-day service. Or ship that 60-pound suitcase from Miami to San Francisco for $63.78 each way.

Not only will you avoid having to lug your luggage through endless airport concourses, but chances are that UPS will do a better job of not losing your shipment than your airline will (and if UPS does misplace it, at least the company will feel bad about it.)

Although Pete Mitchell, director of business-to-business sales for the luggage manufacturer Samsonite, told the New York Times he often travels with one-of-a-kind items because he is reluctant to send them via a shipping service, he probably didn’t read the fine print in his airline's lost-and-damaged-luggage policy. Airline policies don’t cover business samples and trade-show materials if something goes amiss. They’re in the same category as cash, valuables, jewelry, and electronics.

What airline baggage policies don’t cover
At least when you ship FedEx or UPS, you can declare a higher value and insure your business items. In fact, before you pack for your next flight, it’s a good idea to have a look at what your airline will not take responsibility for should your checked bags be lost or damaged. Here’s American’s list, for example, which is pretty standard for the industry:

“Antiques, artifacts, artwork, books and documents, china, computers and other electronic equipment, computer software, fragile items (including child/infant restraint devices such as strollers and car seats), eyeglasses, prescription sunglasses, non-prescription sunglasses and all other eyewear and eye/vision devices whether lenses are glass, plastic, or some other material, furs, heirlooms, items carried in the passenger compartment of the aircraft, liquids, medicines, money, perishable items, photographic, video and optical equipment, precious metals, stones or jewelry, securities and negotiable papers, silverware, samples, unique or irreplaceable items or any other similar valuable items.”

Note the “samples” bit, all you road warriors.

United excludes these items as well, and also mentions “business effects” in its disclaimer — which probably includes your press kits and all those fridge magnets you were going to give away at the trade show.

So tell your airline "No, thanks," next time it tries to hit you with baggage fees. Plan ahead, tell your hotel (or branch office or family) that you’re expecting a shipment and to hold it until your arrival, and save yourself some money and a backache.

© 2008 Imaginova Corp.


MSN Privacy . Legal
© 2008
Comments:11 Replies - Latest reply on 2008-04-24
Posted by MSCANTBEWRONG on 2008-04-24:
With all of the theft going on when checking luggage at the airports, sending it ahead of time seems like a viable option.
Posted by Principissa on 2008-04-24:
Yes it does. Especially if you are flying to a friend or relatives house here in the states. It's not the extra fees that disgust me, it's the theft of people's belongings. You can't lock your bags because they will cut them open, you can't hide your valuables on your person because they will find them and if they can't be brought with you they will be confiscated. The passenger never wins anymore.
Posted by MSCANTBEWRONG on 2008-04-24:
Exactly...but if you mail or ship your luggage, chances are it won't be opened and all of your stuff may actually make it to your destination. That's what I liked about the article...
Posted by Principissa on 2008-04-24:
Same with me. It may get there a day or so after you if you don't time it right, but it will get there. I would just carry 2 pairs of underwear and maybe a change of clothes just in case it got there after I did. I may just do this when we go see my mom in Florida in September.
Posted by Anonymous on 2008-04-24:
Another tip--always weigh your luggage at home before going to the airport--if you don't ship it. We just put it on our home scale. Many times we have been over and have been able to just weed out stuff we really don't need. It's always been accurate for us.

The international carriers used to allow 75 pounds of luggage (who can carry that?). But, they have probably scaled back as well. As MS said, check with your individual carrier on-line before flying. You can save quite a bit of money.
Posted by Principissa on 2008-04-24:
We use one suitcase for the 4 of us when we travel. It's easier that way. We normally stay at a relatives house so it's also good for us because we don't have to pack a lot of clothes. We can just do our laundry at mommy's or my dad's house.
Posted by Anonymous on 2008-04-24:
Geez--Princi, that's very nice you can travel so light.

When my daughter was a teenager, she would pack so many shoes that we had to let her overflow into our suitcases. Our son always traveled so much lighter. There is a big difference. Now that our daughter travels on business, she has learned that traveling light is so much easier.
Posted by Slimjim on 2008-04-24:
This is a viable option if you don't need to accompany certain pieces of luggage, especially on a return trip. I'm guessing the ever rising fuel costs have driven passenger airlines to this concept.
Posted by Dan on 2008-04-24:
There are actually companies out there that specialize in shipping luggage for you now. They cost more than UPS or Fedex, but offer door to door service and guaranteed devliveries. I read an article about them awhile back but I don't remember their names. Just google "luggage shipping" to read about them.
Posted by MSCANTBEWRONG on 2008-04-24:
Thanks for the info chemman!!
Posted by Arlene on 2008-04-24:
That's what I was saying in an earlier post, we're mailing part of our stuff to my son's for vacation because we'll have the dogs with us and it'll just be a lot easier! One large suitcase at MAYBE 40 pounds, one small wheeled suitcase for the dogs stuff and their wire kennel will be all folded up and zip tied...can't hide anything in it...we'll tape name and other info to the tray that goes inside so it gets where its going. Hubby has his meds he will keep right with him and I'll have a handbag and a small canvas tote for things the dogs will need in-flight.
Definitely going light this time.

Your Name:
(displayed with your comment)
Your E-mail:

Your Experience/Advice:
Check spelling

By clicking submit you agree that you have read and accept the Terms of Service & Privacy Policy.

Note: All comments are reviewed by a moderator before being published. Please be sure to read our guidelines before commenting.