My Points Has Paid Me Over $200 and Counting!
I have been using MyPoints for about a year now and have not had a problem. I was reading the reviews here and thought I should write one to let everyone know that not everyone has problems with the site.
Typically I use their Bonus Mail to get my 5 points at a time although I have done several trial periods (one for Rhapsody and one for LifeLock) to get more points - 1000 and 500 respectively. I have also shopped through their site for things I can buy online and have signed up for DirecTV through their site (10,000 points).
There have been several times (although not the majority) that I have not been awarded points. On those occasions, I emailed them a copy of the confirmation email and then I got the points within 5 days. They usually send an email within 24 hours to say they are looking into it. If they need more information, they email me again. Otherwise, they just email me after a couple of days to say the points were awarded. Once, when I signed up for DirecTV, I accidentally used the wrong email address. I emailed them after the 30 days to see if the points were awarded anyway. I just changed out the email address in the confirmation email and the points were awarded.
I typically redeem for $25 gift cards since I want them as soon as I can get them. So far I have received over $200 and I have another $50 pending.
I see people complain about this, but it is an optional service. Even with a few glitches (one being that I have never received points for their MaxPoints offers where you sign up for newsletters), the majority of the program works well. I get all of my points for bonus mail, most of my shopping points, and all of my click through to offer points without any problems. If you typically buy things online, there is no reason not to use this program since you can still get points on your credit card and get extra points and money back for shopping you would do anyway!