Feedburner count

Pep Boys Tire Service

Star Star Empty star Empty star Empty star
34 Reviews & Complaints

Most Popular | Newest | More Options >
More filter options:
Pep Boys Tire Service Rip-off Scam
Posted by NoPEP on 10/30/2008
LOUISVILLE, KENTUCKY -- In April 2008 I had a flat and took my vehicle to Pep Boys to have it fixed. I was told there was a hole in the sidewall and it couldn't be fixed and must be replaced. New tire $135.00.

I was also told my remaining three tires were dangerously thin and should be replaced. I agreed. 4 tires plus balancing alignment and old tire disposal $485.00.

I instructed that the spare tire be placed back under the truck as a spare (had never been on the ground until the flat: 9-miles).

When I went to pick up the truck, I checked the spare. It was one of the worn-out tires! The new spare had been removed from the wheel and a worn-out tire mounted in it's place! So I had four new tires and a worn out spare. I demanded the new spare tire back (I knew the make and size) and had to leave for n appointment.

My wife went to get the truck. I told her to check. Sure enough, the tire had not been replaced. She called me, I called them. My wife left.

On the THIRD attempt to pick the truck up I called ahead and was told the tire had been replaced. When I arrived, it had not. So I made a bit of a scene so the waiting customers could hear as I detailed what they tried THREE TIMES! The service guy just shrugged and grunted as if he'd tried but was caught.

While I waited, they pulled the truck in and got my spare and put it on the wheel and back under the truck. They slid the keys across the counter I asked to see the guy who changed the tire and they paged him. Without warning, I asked him if he'd balanced the tire. He hadn't.
Back on the rack.

Five months later, October 2008: Flat tire. AAA swapped the spare for the flat. Back to Pep Boys. I had purchased a ROAD HAZARD WARRANTY.

The tire was not repairable. Hole in the sidewall. The odds against this are impossible!

New tire $165.00. But I have warranty! Couldn't find it in the 'new system', and didn't even try in the 'old system'. So we started over again. After remaining resolute, the warranty was found in the 'old system' and the tire was replaced for $50.00.

But when I went to get the truck, I noticed the spare was just swinging from the mounting cable under the rear of the truck! I HAD NOT BEEN WINCHED into place! It could simply fall off at highway speed! Back into the shop where the service guy tightened the spare into place and said, THAT OUGHTA HOLD IT.


Pep Boys tried to steal the brand new spare tire THREE TIMES!

Two flat tires, both with suspicious non-repairable sidewall punctures.

Couldn't find our waranty in their 'system'. Didn't look, didn't try. Tried to charge full price.

Left the job dangerously undone.

Arrogant attitude, disrespectful. Got caught, knew it, and just shrugged it off. No apology for the half-done job.

Spare tire scam. BEWARE!

Read 1 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by MRM on 2008-10-30:
Thank you, "NoPep" for alerting your readers of this particular store in KY. I applaud you for standing your ground when something is not right.
Close commentsAdd reply

StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty Star
Rebate Scam
Posted by Rw346 on 12/31/2012
DALLAS, TEXAS -- I went in for a set of tires. I was offered a special $129 per tire, buy 3 and get 1 tire free. I accepted the special. When my car was ready I found out that the free tire was a mail-in rebate. I felt tricked but okay I will mail it in. I paid $664.57. I went home and followed all the instructions for my mail-in rebate.

Today I received a postcard declining my rebate. They say I did not buy the road hazard. These people are a joke. Their employee told me I qualified for the rebate. Does he not know the requirements of the rebate. Furthermore, I would have bought a different product If I had known all of this. I will never spend another red cent with Pep Boys.
Read 4 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by trmn8r on 2012-12-31:
Rebate terms are usually stated on the application. Did the form not list this as a term/condition? The employee should have also warned you that you didn't qualify. Pep Boys is pretty much the WallsMart of the auto repair industry.
Posted by At Your Service on 2012-12-31:
Not that I'm a fan of Pep Boys, but I am a pretty big fan of mail in rebates.

The rebate qualifications would have been outlined within the original rebate form. Before mailing said rebate, you make sure you include an original sales receipt which the retailer will normally provide. Make copies of everything required and post it at the local post office, obtaining a receipt for the mailing. This services as proof of the date the rebate was sent.

My guess is that the rebate you're referring to does outline the qualifications, including that of road hazard insurance. It sounds as if you didn't retain a copy of the rebate form to have anything to reference.

If one knows that they're less than organized, then you're wise to not utilize mail in rebates. But for those who are, rebates can be a wonderful value.

Thanks for posting.
Posted by yoke on 2013-01-01:
Since the employee stated the OP qualified for the rebate then it was up to the employee to state he also needed the road hazard insurance. Pep Boys are the biggest scam going on in auto repair.
Posted by ok4now on 2013-01-01:
I priced four Michelin tires, including the road hazard warranty at Pep Boys. "Guaranteed lowest price." Really? Costco was $230 cheaper for the same deal. They can keep their rebate.
Close commentsAdd reply

Pep Boys - Tire Repair & Road Hazard Ripoff
Posted by Trashstuff22 on 11/28/2011
IRVING, TEXAS -- I bought 4 new tires about a year ago and had gotten a nail in one tire. I used PepBoys free tire repair service that came with the purchase of the tires. They would only put in a plug (which I thought was illegal to do these days). About 6 months later, the plug started leaking. Rather than take it back to PepBoys for repair, I went to the friendly and helpful folks at Discount Tire, that also repairs flat tires for free (even if you did not buy your tires from them) and they always use a patch for the repair. Well, they said that the plug had enlarged the hole so much that it could not be repaired, plus they discovered a bulge in the sidewall and said I should take it back to PepBoys for coverage on the Road Hazard that PepBoys made me purchase when I bought the tires in order to get the rebate they were offering. These were 75,000 mile tires and I had only put 12,000 miles on the tire (1/6 of its life). They would only credit me $36.00 on a new tire, plus I had to repurchase road hazard and pay a tire balance cost. So my cost came to what the original price was on the tire when I purchased it! I will never use PepBoys for ANYTHING again.
Read 2 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by ok4now on 2011-11-28:
Excellent post. I have seen these big sales from Pep Boys and wondered what the fine print is. Similar to an extended warranty. They make it sound wonderful until you have to use it. Now they make you jump through hoops trying to collect. You learned a hard lesson at Pep Boys.
Posted by Mad Ash on 2014-03-20:
I experienced the same problem with Pep Boys where they would not replace a tire under warranty after I have had two tires with the same issue..... but I refuse to buy new tires from them I am taking them to Court if it is not replaced. I will speak to there Corporate Office and go from there. It will cost them more money to go to court than it would have to replace the tires! to be continued.....
Close commentsAdd reply

Tire service
Posted by Qrt7 on 01/10/2013
WEST SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS -- I have Aluminum rims that can be a pain in the neck with slow leaks at the beads. The guy who changed my tires busted his butt cleaning the beads (I didn't even mention the leaks) and cleaning the mounting surfaces on the van. I expected a quick unprofessional job. (how professional can changing tires be?) The guy (Noel) impressed me. I was watching him work on the van and thought "I wonder if I should give him a tip" Then I thought "I'm gonna give him a $5) Then I thought "I'm gonna give him a ten." I tip waitresses much more for less service! Thanks Noel...

Add reply

Tire Rebate
Posted by LAWDOG777 on 05/24/2008

I bought five tires from Pep Boys. I was given rebate form to mail off with a copy of my receipt. The rebate was lost by the rebate center. They told me I would have to reapply and that would take 4-6 weeks to process and mail my check to me. Now I have waited 8 weeks prior. When I asked to first speak to a manager I got the run around, than the person eventually tried to transfer me to a manager.

The manager was unprofessional and rude he told me to resubmit my rebate. I was asking for some kind of compensation for my loss he told me to resubmit it. He was rude I told him I wanted to complain, he told me to mail it in than he hung-up on me.
Read 1 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by Anonymous on 2008-05-24:
I must assume that the CSR told the poster that the rebate center 'lost' the initial documentation. It is not unreasonable to request the consumer to re-apply for the rebate. However, it IS unreasonable to delay the rebate, which should have been expedited due to the loss of the initial application.
Close commentsAdd reply

Posted by #137 on 01/04/2008
SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA -- On 12/02/06, I purchased 4 new tires for my car, paid for everything even the road hazard warranty, when it come time to have the tires rotated I first was told that I had to leave the car for at least 4 to 5 hours, well because I'm handicapped that wasn't possible for me!, so the manager said that I could make an appointment to come in and have it done (rotation). But even with an appointment he said he couldn't guarantee that he could doing even then, saying that if someone came in at the same time as my appointment that I'd probably still would have to leave the car anyway, at this point I felt as if he was giving me a run around, so I left feeling like I just got the runaround of my life! Now 8,000 miles later the front tires had worn so badly from not being able to have my rotation done it not only ruined my c.v. joints on my front wheel drive car but I ended up picking up a screw in one of the front tires giving me a leak in one of the front tires, making me having to go back to pep boys to see if they could do something for me they told me that they would pull my car in and check it out, it's funny because they didn't waste anytime bringing my car in and while they had my car in their shop I decided to take a walk into the garage where my car was and that was when I caught the worker under my hood and had my air cleaner wing nuts in his hand proceeding to get ready to remove my air breather! I said excuse me but what are you doing under my hood when I'm here for just tire service, his excuse was oh!

We do this to all the cars we call it a 5-point checkup, well I told him that I do my own checking under the hood and told him to kindly put the screws back on the airbreather and close my hood and just do what was suppose to be done on the tires and not under my hood, well he seemed like he had an attitude over it, but hey why was he under my hood? Between him and the tire manager I ended up being charged for 2 more new tires with the warranty charges I already had on the previous ones that were still under warranty, I feel I got ripped off because the tires only had 8,000 miles on them and if they had rotated them when they were suppose too they would still look like new like the rear ones still do! I still have the 2 out of 4 on the back but got charged for the 2 front ones and I'll never recommend pep boys here in San Diego, store #978 to anyone unless they want to be ripped off or worse yet have that gang banging looking Mexican dude they have working in the garage trying to sabotoge your vehicle by putting his hands under the hood when your only there for tire service it was a good thing I walked in when I did or it would of cost more then $249.54 the first time for 4 new tires, and then 8,000miles later be charged another $95.25 to replace two of the four you had already bought the year before!

I never believed the rumors about what goes on at that pep boys, about them doing things to your vehicle so you'd have to come back, until I experienced it for myself! The next time I'll go back to Discount Tires, like I had done in the past, I never went through all this crap with tires, especially with the ordeal with catching the guy under my hood?, that was nervy of him! Sometimes deals are to good to be true especially with their recent one where you buy 3 and get the 4th tire free yea right they probably raised the price of the tires to civer the cost of the 4th one: it's not pep boys fault it's the crooks that they hire that give them a bad name! "NEVER AGAIN"!!!

I haven't decided yet if I'm going to go see my lawyer but if I do they will be the first to know!.
Read 7 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by Anonymous on 2008-01-05:
Usually with a road hazard warranty, the tires are pro-rated for the wear that is on them. Otherwise everyone would drive over nails when their tires are worn and never have to buy a new one.

If your front tires were that worn and your cv joint ruined, you probably need a wheel alignment. Let me guess. You didn't get one when you bought the tires.
Posted by Hugh_Jorgen on 2008-01-05:
I have to agree with Rob - there's something else going on with your front end if you ate up two new tires in 8K miles - find a mechanic you can trust and have them check it out.
Posted by Anonymous on 2008-01-05:
I too will have to agree with Robf and Hugh. Sometimes it can be as simple as they left the valve stem in the new tire because they didn't know it fell in when they changed the old one. I have had this happen more then once and it will eat up a tire in a short time, makes the car feel out of alignment.

PS. Happy New Year Hugh!
Posted by runaway on 2008-01-05:
According to your letter, you were upset they couldn't guarrantee you an appointment time and left without getting the work done....and now it's their fault you didn't get the work done?
Also, if you specified you didn't want the other checks done I can see being upset at someone under your hood, but there's no need to look like an ignorant a$$h@le with your "gang-banging" racist comments for someone trying to do his job.
I'm not fond of Pep Boys, but I actually feel for them having to deal with someone like you.
Posted by #137 on 2008-01-05:
They give you a runaround and as far as the road warranty they already were paid when I first bought the tires and when I went back the 2nd time they charged me again, and as far as the under the hood problem they have no business being under the hood if your there for tires, as far as the wheel alignment the front end was in perfect condition prior to taking it to pep boys,and your language on your comments matches your intellegence or maybe that was the way your parents raised you I don't know but but it is not what you would exspect from anyone that would be intellegent, so the person with that fowl mouth should take a good look at yourself in a mirror and say do you kiss your women with that dirty mouth too?, awlful language isn't it, grow up and be an adult and not a fool!, I also have witnesses and proof of my situation and I'm sure my lawyer will agree also!, Have a nice day and that person with the "POTTY MOUTH" check yourself and grow up liitle kid!.
Posted by runaway on 2008-01-05:
hmmm, lectures on MY language from a racist pig....the racist part already proves your intelligence.
Posted by Anonymous on 2008-01-05:
Key word here, proration. Tires are prorated based on the miles used. You only get a new tire at zero cost if you put zero miles on the tire. If the tire has a 30,000 mile life and you put 15,000 miles on it then they will give you about 50% replacement value. Road hazard does not replace tires for free with 8,000 miles on them.
Close commentsAdd reply

StarStarStarStarEmpty Star
Great Customer Service and Good Prices
Posted by Lrandant on 07/16/2013
They have great deals such as buy 3 tires get one free and a points reward program. Great customer service and the manager was extremely helpful.
Add reply

StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty Star
Careless Service to Customer
Posted by Atomic0007 on 06/22/2013
VALLEJO, CALIFORNIA -- On average how long will take to repair a tire? I'm very disappointed of this store/service dept. I have been in the store multiple times and seems like they need to provide better service. All I hear is customer complaints service not been on time even when appt has been setup in advance. There is a reason you expect to get help when you need it, especially if you had an appointment.

Today 6/22/2013 I took my car in because I have a flat tire on my car and just made it to the store. I was told that I have to leave my car or wait 5 hours. Come on, I see they can do better but always so negative on customer help, they like to exaturate so they don't have to help you especially if the repair will not make any profit on flat repair since its free. They rather make you wait all day instead help you on your needs and rather fair pn the wait. Really do you need to wait 5 hours for a tire repair?

This is my second experience on same person and store. Last time I did let it pass on because just had the tire of the vehicle and was ok to just drop off and pick up the next day. But not today. It seems like they deferred service where is no profit to make.

Read 1 RepliesAdd reply

User Replies:Close comments

Posted by SBo on 2013-06-24:
Pep Boys put the wrong size cap on my oil pan after an oil change and stripped the threads so that I was leaking oil and had to replace the oil pan at a cost of over $800. Several mechanics, car dealers and garages have told me to STAY AWAY. Pep Boys hires people off the street that are not properly trained. Let the buyer beware.
Close commentsAdd reply

StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty Star
Worst Place to Go for Tires
Posted by Corey3139 on 05/23/2013
HOLLYWOOD, FLORIDA -- I needed new tires, I decided to try Pep Boys. I was pleased in the beginning, they found the tires that I wanted, it went downhill from there. It was expensive for starters, 850 dollars for a mazda3. It took them almost 5 hours to complete the job, and once they were done and aligned it, the car completely pulled to the left. I came back, they rotated the tires, still had the problem. The next day I went to Firestone, they said the tires had a defect, so I went back to Pep Boys and I told them what Firestone said, they refused to admit that the tire had a defect. They replaced all 4 tires, I haven't had a problem until today, its been 5000 miles since I got their tires and now I need new ones. I went back to them and said they can't give me new ones, they blamed it all on me.
Add reply

Great experience
Posted by Sanders.david91 on 05/03/2013
Great service at Mechanicsburg Pep Boys. I got tires shocks and service. The maintenance manager Dwayne and his staff took good care of my car.
Add reply

Top of Page | Next Page >