Preview Review

Next Review

Sears Mattresses Consumer Reviews

Most Popular | Newest | More Options >
More filter options:
Unable To Return After Doing One Exchange On A Mattress
StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarBy -
Rating: 1/51

ORANGE, CALIFORNIA -- I purchased a mattress 2/24/2017 from Sears as I had sat on a mattress the week before while clothes shopping and it felt so nice and plush. Sales gal knew I wanted softer bed, showed me the Beautyrest Chloe which felt good in store but when delivered on 3/6, it ended up being way too firm. Waited till the 31st day to call back and go with the softer cushy one I originally looked at, the Platinum Hailey and called to do comfort exchange.

No one reminded me this was the only return or exchange I could do. I knew I could not do another comfort exchange but when this Hailey was delivered and we slept couple nights on it, I realized it was not as plush and cushy as one in the store and thus called on 4/24/2017 to return department.

Either the guy on the phone who helped me wasn't listening or he gave me wrong info. He was well aware I had already done a comfort exchange and told me I still had until May 4th to do a return on this second mattress. He said to use the same case number as I had used for first exchange and someone would call me within 72 hours to set up a pick up date. He said he would start the process for the return.

I then get a call two days later which is today and a message left on my home number saying I cannot do another comfort exchange, she said nothing about a return and that was that so I called to customer service and in the meantime I am aware that the paperwork says only one return or comfort exchange but this is not the same softness as was in the store and fact I was told return could happen I wanted to talk to a manager as all the reps I talked to at two different numbers all said they can't do anything, that is their policy so basically live with it.

I was put on hold for a half hour while this Rena at 888-566-5561 was supposed to be getting a manager for me to talk to, however, she came back on the line (I am sure she was hoping I would hang up) she gave me the song and dance that she had spoken to a manager and they can't help me. I prefer to hear it from someone higher up and will go to corporate to ask why in the world when I would be willing to spend more money on a better mattress there at Sears and pay any restock fees etc. wouldn't they let me do a return and they can make more money off of me.

Worst customer service and I am so sorry I did not go to Macy's. I bought my other pillow top at Robinsons-May and it lasted 13 years, Macy's is on the same line. I should have known better when Sears is planning on closing stores and I knew this but wanted to give them a chance. I was just given the runaround and am now stuck with a mattress that is not very comfortable for being a plush pillow top.

How do I know I even got the right one for exchange, I got nothing with the new mattress info on it, all I have is original paperwork on the first one I ordered. I am wondering if I got the Hailey firm instead now. I cannot get anyone to help me and I think it stinks to not care about your customers.

Replies
Advertisement
Poorly designed Mattress Set
StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarBy -
Rating: 1/51

BEL AIR, MARYLAND -- What a horrific experience I am enduring. I had not purchased a new mattress in about 10 years. The pillow top Sealy I purchased 10 years ago was priceless in every way. So I hear Sears is having a mattress sale and I'm all in. In December 2016 I purchased a Euro Sealy twin and paid about $450.00 on sale. Within (2) weeks it sagged in the middle. I called Sears and figured I would upgrade the mattress and thought MAYBE it was just a bottom of the line mattress.

So I then way upgraded to a Plush pillow top Madelyn that was $1,539.99 and on sale for $950.00 give or take and after a month here we go again. Only this time no one wants to take responsibility for it and I am expected to tear down the set, measure this way and that way for an exact amount of sagging and so forth. I am supposed to have all the warranty tags from the set that was tagged at every end possible which I removed and so on. God forbid they would come out and see for themselves.

I told them I had never owned a cell phone, had no camera to download or upload but none of that mattered. They suggested I purchase a disposable camera and then go from there. Hah! What a joke. Even when I told them I was caring for an elderly Mother that had just had back surgery to try and relieve pain from Osteo and had no time to be dealing with this it still didn't matter. All I want is either a refund or for their recovery team to come and pick it up but I'm still getting the run around. DO NOT purchase anything from SEARS! Seriously. I am not only out almost a thousand dollars I still need to purchase proper bedding. May God bless them!

Replies
Don't Buy a Mattress Here!
StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarBy -
Rating: 1/51

AURORA, ILLINOIS -- The sales staff is nice, however the Sears delivery team brought our new Kaden Serta Perfect Sleeper Queen and didn't set the frame up properly, they left the middle bar laying under the bed unused. Within a couple months we noticed our bed significantly sagging and incredibly uncomfortable, worse than what we had. Even though the test they had us perform proved something was wrong with the mattress, they refused to refund our money after many attempts, trying to get them to do anything was a complete waste of time. We spent over $700 as a newly married couple and the mattress has sat in our basement for years now, such a complete waste of time and money.

Replies
Beauty Rest Hybrid Silver
StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarBy -
Rating: 1/51

MYRTLE BEACH, SOUTH CAROLINA -- Do NOT purchase a mattress online with Sears. Their warranty will not hold up even after calling 3 days after delivery. David Store Manager at Coastal Grand Mall Myrtle Beach said OH WELL NOTHING he can do or will do. 2068.00$$ wasted. Purchased online May 10, 2017. Delivered May 12th. Called about defective May 15. I have been lied to, hung up on so many times, transferred to non working numbers, told they were coming to pick it up, told they would call in 24 hrs, told that it could be returned and had all my info erased, no file, not even my order could be found.

July 3rd on 3rd mgr trying to rectify the situation and they keep passing the buck. David store mgr insisted Sears doesn't operate this way and someone would call AGAIN by July 6th. July FOURTH at 4:30 pm while at the beach Sears calls and immediately changes their minds AGAIN on what they were offering. Now I can NOT return it and I have to pay them 70.00 for them to pick up and exchange their poorly constructed mattress. When I said I don't agree, she hung up AGAIN. Back to store on July 5th.

Talked to David store mgr for 2nd time and he said there was nothing else he could do or would do. Coastal Grand Mall Myrtle Beach SC. Do not waste your money. Beauty Rest Silver Hybrid queen. 2068.00$$ wasted on a defective bed not 2 months old.

Replies
Advertisement
Mattress. Beautyrest Messala-11 PlushAppliance
StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarBy -
Rating: 1/51

ELIZABETHTOWN, KENTUCKY -- Differently not the mattress tried out at this Sears store. And why would a customer have to wait 30 days to return a product they are clearly not satisfied with. Why would Sears want to treat their customers this way. This mattress was very expensive and was expected to to be the last mattress purchased, given our age and all. 15% restocking fee? Really? On top of a pickup fee? The "break in" period for a mattress is a bunch of crap and wish I had not fallen for it.

Replies
Mattress Sagging After 1 Year
StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarBy -
Rating: 1/51

MERRILLVILLE, INDIANA -- I purchased queen mattress set along with bed frame from Sears. After 1 year mattress was sagging almost 3 inches down the center. I emailed all the pictures and information required. I was denied because they said the frame didn't meet the requirements. After numerous calls, I got nowhere. I went to Sears because I trusted that I would be sold quality products. Why would they sell me a frame that was not the required frame for my mattress set? Now I'm stuck with a new saggy mattress. Extremely dissatisfied!!!

Replies
Tortured and Robbed
StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarBy -
Rating: 1/51

CHICAGO, MASSACHUSETTS -- We took delivery of a Simmons Beauty rest Mattress purchased at our local Sears store and immediately noticed it had a chemical odor. My wife refused to sleep on it and I proceeded to call the 800 number to try to resolve the problem. I was told that I would have to use the mattress for 30 days before I could return it and that the smell would dissipate in about a week. I was also told that unless the mattress was defective I would be charged a 15% restocking fee as well as a delivery charge for picking up the mattress.

After airing it out for a week I wrapped the mattress in waterproof cover to mitigate the remaining smell and tried to sleep on it (alone). This was definitely NOT the same Mattress I lied on at the Sears store. It was considerably harder, akin to lying on a carpeted floor. After three hours I couldn't take it anymore, the pain in my back and shoulders forced me to head for the couch. The next few nights were the same. At that point I went on Amazon and ordered a 3" memory foam topper. I looked around the Internet and found that those who sold mattress' recommend "breaking a new mattress in". I was also told about the “break in” by the Sears people.

I went back to the Sears store to lie on the display model to confirm that it was different than the one in our bedroom. While at the store I was told that the display model was "broken in by all the people who come try out the mattresses and that it was only a matter of time before my mattress would be soft like the store model". This Sears is in a mall that is clearly dying.

In the 5 or so hours over several visits that we spent in the store we were the sole customers, all the salesperson's time was devoted to our bed sale. I don't know who the people who broke in the beds were but they weren't around when we were there. We only spent about 10 minutes on that particular mattress. I concluded that the mattress in the store was definitely not the same as the toxic torture rack that was in my bedroom.

Finally, the topper arrived and I was able to coax my wife into vacating the guest bedroom. It has been almost a month, we have cornered the market on Ibuprofen and constantly have the slight scent of formaldehyde/gasoline in the back of our sinus. The topper helped a little but this bed is still unbearable. We went to change the sheets yesterday and a soon as the plastic cover came off the toxic fumes filled the room. There are now body pod indentations with a ridge in the middle of the bed, it isn't going to get more "broken in".

I called the 800 number again, insisting that this mattress was defective because of the toxic odor. I was told that I could purchase another bed but would still have to pay the 15% restocking fee plus a charge to pick up the other mattress. The bottom line is that Sears thinks it can bring you a sack of dung to sleep on and that you have to live with it for thirty days and then pay big to have endured the experience.

Replies
Buyer Beware!
StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarBy -
Rating: 1/51

ROANOKE, VIRGINIA -- After years of trouble with TempurPedic mattresses we went to Sears and purchased a top of the line Simmons Beautyrest Black pillow top mattress and box springs, spending almost $3K, thinking it would hold up and appreciating the 60 day Comfort guarantee should we not like it as much once we got it home. The mattress delivery went well, and we enjoyed the mattress but by 2 months the sagging had begun and in the 7th month we completed jumping through the hoops to satisfy the warranty, demonstrating a clean mattress, strong foundation, and a 1.5" sag.

We were told to pick out whatever mattress we wanted - no refund if we selected something less expensive and if it was more we would pay the difference. Furthermore, no more comfort guarantee- so if you pick something different and don't like it, too bad. Not wanting to make another mistake I read all I could find... which led me to realize that most all mattresses sag, the manufacturers consider this to be "normal". The more plush (more foam inside) the more it will sag, so pillow top mattresses are the worst. I learned that air beds and latex mattresses have the fewest issues so I went back to Sears to see if they carried either of these - No, no they don't.

I continued to research and in doing so learned that all beds contain fire retardant chemicals but some retailers will sell you a bed w/o the chemicals if you have a physician prescription. Not so with Sears - Serta, Simmons and Stearns and Foster all insist on giving you the chemicals and their customer's health is not a concern for Sears. My daughter and husband have both suffered health issues that have reportedly come from these dangerous chemicals.

I contacted Sears explaining my dilemma - obtaining another mattress that will eventually sag and make my family sick was not what I wanted. I asked for a pro-rated store credit. While I had offers of both store credit and a refund - in the end the people offering them were misinformed.

I took it all the way to the executive offices, thinking surely they would be empowered to keep a customer but no - they just don't feel they can do anything about it. They told me their only recourse, and thus mine, was to take the manufacturer's warranty. I contacted the manufacturer and they tell me I must deal with Sears-what a hot potato! No one stands behind these expensive mattresses with short lives. After buying from Sears for 30 years, I will never again purchase anything from them. Instead I purchased a mattress from Sleep Essentials in Roanoke - chemical free latex that won't sag. See ** for mattress education. I wish I had done this before buying from Sears!

Replies
Advertisement
Case # ** - Howell. Mattress Replacement Denied
StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarBy -
Rating: 1/51

SOUTHPORTLAND, MAINE -- REPLACEMENT DENIED! I sent Sears emails with at least 15 different photos clearly showing my mattress is sagging two inches. I received several emails from various Sears representatives from different departments trying to confuse me with different requirements and requesting more and different photos.

After clearing proving the mattress is defective I was denied because it had a stain on it! Really it's been 5 years! What do they care or did they plan to resale it? What does a stain have to do with it? The top is not tight which also indicates its defect. Why bother to have a warranty they have no intention of replacing any mattress ever. I will never step foot in Sears stores again. This is Sears (Sears Mattress Solutions) Member Service email address rrpos@searshc.com.

Replies
HORRIBLE SERVICE
StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarEmpty StarBy -
Rating: 1/51

LAKE HOPATCONG, NEW JERSEY -- We purchased our new mattress before Christmas 2015. We requested delivery for Monday January 4th. When we were being rung up, by I must say a very sweet and helpful woman (the only good experience of this whole thing) she said that we will get a phone call the day before with a window but that we could call the day before and request a window. She also said that if we do not get the correct window we can call them back and they will help us to reschedule for another window that day. Timing for delivery was very important to us because of the work schedule. Great.

I called the day before and requested the latest window we could get. The woman on the phone said that she could put us in for 12-5 pm. Great, we can deal with that. I get a phone call about an hour or so later, automated, saying that our window was 10 am - 12 pm. So I call back and explain that I had called earlier and that I couldn't do that time. She said that I should have called before 2 pm if I wanted to request a time -- which was NOT told to me when checking out otherwise I would have done that. She also said that I should have requested a time when I was being rung up at the store -- also was NOT presented to us or we would have asked.

She called the warehouse and the best she could do for us was 11:30-1:30 pm window. We ended up just keeping the 10 am - 12 pm window so that he could take a half-day and hopefully go back to work after 12 pm. My fiancé takes a half-day the morning of the 4th.

I am driving to work and get a call at 8:30 am saying that our delivery has been rescheduled for Saturday the 9th (which out our approval and I actually told the woman the day before we would be out of the state on the 9th) because the manufacture delayed the product. WHAT? AT 8:30 AM YOU ARE TELLING ME THIS? He couldn't help me. Said he was "just the messenger" and couldn't even give me a number to call to reach someone who COULD help me.

I called customer service who told me they can't help me. That the truck left already and there is nothing that could be done. The box spring was backordered and couldn't be delivered until Saturday. No offer to just deliver the mattress. No SOLUTION whatsoever. HORRIBLE service, HORRIBLE customer service. I cancelled my order to which she said "I have already miss. Expect a refund within 7-10 business days". Great. At least you can do one thing right -- CANCEL. Don't buy -- NOT WORTH THE HEADACHE!

Replies
Top of Page | Next Page >

Sears Mattresses Rating:
Star Empty star Empty star Empty star Empty star
1.0 out of 5, based on 22 ratings and
32 reviews & complaints.
Contact Information:
Sears
3333 Beverly Road
Hoffman Estates, IL 60192-3322
847-286-2500 (ph)
www.sears.com
smadvisor@searshc.com
Product/Services
Compare Department Stores