LARGO, FLORIDA -- On May 26, 2014, I purchased a battery from AAA after calling for roadside assistance to jump-start my wife's Mercedes 2010 S550. The battery worked fine until this past Monday, Nov 23, 2015. Call AAA and an hour and a half later, an employee came to our house. He jump-started the vehicle and tested the battery which he claimed passed with a .73A.
Car was driven about ten miles with one stop and back home. Two hours later battery was dead. Called several times and dispatchers and supervisors said there was something wrong with the as the battery passed. About 6 pm on the 23rd, another employee came out and jump started the car. He instructed me to drive car for 15 to 20 minutes and if the car started the next morning, to bring it in to their repair/battery facility. On Tues, Nov 24th, the car started and I brought it in to the AAA station.
I spoke with the owner and he explained that his hands were tied because AAA provides the testers which are set to pass batteries that should be replaced. He also told me that although most batteries fail within the warranty period, AAA Michigan warned him that he has to keep his replacement rate below 11% or he'll lose his franchise. It is noted on AAA battery test strip that "The Average Battery Life in this Region is 23-26 Months." Why would AAA provide a full replacement warranty for 36 month if they know the average battery won't last that long? It is because there is an intent to deny 90% of the claims.
After being denied the replacement battery, the car was brought to our Mercedes-certified mechanic. The battery was tested properly and it failed the load test for that car. The battery had to be replaced. Also noteworthy is that although the AAA battery was the proper size, it was a lead acid battery, but not an AGM battery used by Mercedes Benz.
It is unbelievable that AAA hasn't had a class action suit brought against for this false and deceptive practice. All you have to do is read the negative reviews to know AAA is scamming the public. What about the Attorney Generals office? If enough letters are written, perhaps that office will take action.
I purchased a AAA battery less than 2 yrs ago after being told by a AAA roadside service representative that if I purchase a "AAA BATTERY" I would no longer have to worry about having a dead battery and if anything went wrong with the battery, AAA would replace it, no questions asked. Well, I paid over $120.00 and thought I was getting a good deal, until...on March 2, 2016, I went to pick up my car a day after being released from the ER (legally blind), I found out my battery was dead.
I called AAA for help, they sent a battery tech who was able to jump start my car and told me I would have to get it charged somewhere, and that was it! I explained to him that I was promised it would be replaced free if there was ever a problem, "and you're telling me that I need to look for a place that will charge it?" They told me they rarely replace batteries and their tester hardly ever shows the battery as being dead or bad. I am now realizing that their testers are rigged to avoid replacing their batteries that are under warranty and fail within the 36 month period, when it should be replaced for free!
This scam I will be reported to Consumer Affairs and the BBB. I now realize after 4 calls to AAA in 5 days (1 call I waited over 1 hour and they never showed up Or called), and after keeping the car running for an hour as the AAA rep suggested, trying to recharge the battery on my own, I am still without my car and instead left with a battery that will not charge enough to start my car. All they can tell me is they will send someone out again to check my battery...(with their fixed tester?). No thanks.
ALISO VIEJO, CALIFORNIA -- This is the first negative review I have ever had to write, and hate to do it. But this is deserved. I have been a AAA member for decades, and have a gold membership card with my daughter as co-member. My daughter, who is a college student purchased a new battery from AAA Battery Service because she was stranded and needed a new battery. The batteries came with a 6-year warranty, and a three-year free replacement so she thought it was a good deal. Only one problem, they don't honor the free replacement.
After two years the battery would not hold a charge. I jump started the battery with my car and drove it into my garage to do a brake job. I checked that the alternator was charging the battery correctly and it was putting out 14.25 volts. I had the battery on a charger all morning. It would not hold a charge for more than two hours. There was nothing drawing current from the battery but for about 50 to 70 milliamps when I checked. Totally normal.
I called AAA Roadside Assistance and told them I had a bad battery that my daughter purchased from AAA Battery Service two years ago. I told them it needed to be replaced because it would not hold a charge. They said they would send someone with a replacement battery. Thirty minutes later a tow truck shows up and wants to jump start the car. They totally botched the call. The nice tow truck operator called their HQ to have a battery delivered and said they would be over in 20 minutes. Four hours later and still nobody had shown up. I called again and finally 30 minutes later someone came by and "tested" the battery.
Even though the battery had been charging all day, he said I needed to charge the battery. Hmmm... You think maybe it's bad? He said to drive it for about 30 to 60 minutes to let it charge. Then to take it to an "official" free charging location to have the battery charged before they would even consider replacing it for free. Really? Ludicrous!
Fine, I needed to road test the car after replacing all the brakes anyway. Drove for an hour on the highway and parked the car. Next day, dead again. I shouldn't have to jump through all these hoops to get a "free" replacement battery for a junk battery. I have never had a battery last only two years in my life.
The next day I took the car to Autozone. They even tested it and the alternator and clearly stated it was a bad battery. I bought a new battery and it has been fine for two weeks. Guess what? No more battery problems! I'm cancelling my membership at the end of this year. Auto Club of Southern California.
OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA -- 1/21/2016. Bad idea to purchase AAA battery, because not AAA. Read the warranty:
I am 2 1/2 years into my 36 month battery for $110, now dead, and they need more money, I may put AAA through the hassle of coming out etc., but am sure to be headed to car parts store to put in a real battery and avoid any grief or time wasted, or good money after bad, as documented here by others.
SEAL BEACH, CALIFORNIA -- October, my car wouldn't start. I called AAA (I have been a happy member for 31 years). They tested the battery and alternator, even gave me the print out. I got a new battery from them on the spot and on my way in 20 minutes. December, my car wouldn't start, called AAA. I showed them the paperwork that my battery was only 2 months old. They jumped it, it started and he said all was well. I asked them to run the test and it came back replace battery. The driver looked shocked, he had one in his truck, lucky, not really.
My battery light is on again and my auto repair guy said this morning the battery needs to be replaced. I am not happy. I agree with all the other reviews, DO NOT BUY A BATTERY FROM AAA! I will not be buying an AAA battery again and I have two friends that had the same issue.
ORANGE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA -- I have had AAA Plus for 22 years for 4 family members. In May of 2011 I had a AAA battery installed in one of my cars. In May of 2013, it failed and AAA came out and replaced it. I was so impressed that I have had AAA batteries installed in my daughter's car and our RV since then. On 11/22/15, the same battery needed to be jumped by AAA at the grocery store.
My wife drove the car home and on 11/25/15 it was dead in our garage (3 days later). I called for service and they told me over the phone that it was under warranty. The AAA driver arrived, jumped the battery and run tests, the charging system showed no problems. The driver then told me that the battery was too low to be tested, so while he got it running he said that it needed to be driven to a AAA approved auto repair facility to be charged for 8 hours and then tested. What!
The charging system was fine as my receipt says, I can't take the time right now (while the car is running) to drive it to a AAA repair ship. I removed the battery myself, drove it to Pep Boys, they tested it, it was bad, bought a new battery installed it. Called AAA and asked for a supervisor. I asked Aldo if the battery policy has changed, he said no, policy was followed.
Now I feel real foolish with AAA batteries in my two other cars. Called AAA and canceled service. After reviewing so many complaint sites for AAA and being so surprised, I didn't know of so many of these battery issues concerning AAA.
CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA -- I have been a longtime loyal AAA member. I replaced my 2007 SAAB battery which died in 2011 with a battery provided by AAA. It died in 2013 and then again in 2015. I called AAA and spoke to the call center. The call center said I would get a new battery and it would not cost me. I said I wanted to get a better battery for my car so my complaint was filed with customer service. I was promised a call back by Thursday or Friday which was about 2-3 days later so I waited and borrowed a friend's car.
By Friday evening customer service had still not called me back so I called back to the service center to see if I could speak to anyone. I was told that they would call me. Now, I had been without my car for a few days so I had a new battery installed by AAA under reservation of rights that I would request a refund and a new battery of my choice. Again I was assured that was the best option since AAA customer service had not called.
Finally, customer service called and would not replace the battery with a credit so I could buy a new battery. I am dissatisfied with AAA. I am looking for other folks who have been involved with AAA battery replacement program within the last 5 years and feel that their battery replacement service and AAA consumer service was not satisfactory.
CHERRY HILL, NEW JERSEY -- AAA Member for decades. Ecstatic about their new battery truck that comes to your house and replaces your car battery for about the same price as a Sears DieHard, which I've also used for decades. Battery dies within one year. AAA tech comes to house, tells me there's something wrong with my car. Dealer charges $90 for diagnostics to tell me the battery is dead as a doornail. AAA goes to dealer to replace battery. Car runs fine. When this battery dies - I'm going back to DieHard at Sears. I hope it's not this year, but I bet it will be. I love AAA - will not buy their batteries again. Absolute crap. I don't buy crap.
VIERA, FLORIDA -- My 80 yr old dad had car serviced at local station and bought a new battery. One week later he left car lights on in garage overnight and, no surprise, had a dead battery in the morning. He called AAA, who sent their battery assist car to help. They told him battery needed to replaced, sold him a new battery at a cost of $141, and took his 1 week old battery away with them.
Complaints to AAA supervisor John # ** fell on deaf ears, who stated this is "buyer's remorse." Supervisor claims battery failed testing according to their records, despite the fact that the original white copy receipt has a blank area where failed battery test code should be written. AAA is ripping off old people - shame on them!